Awarded, never delivered, never withdrawn: the National Lottery and Saycom halt the furniture contract for the sales outlets, and six years on Wycor loses its interest — but not the right to have the Lottery pay the costs
The Council of State declares inadmissible, for lack of a current interest, the action by Wycor (formerly Wyckaert Houtconstructies) against the award to Saycom of the lot for fixed furniture for the National Lottery’s sales outlets, because the Lottery and Saycom had definitively halted performance in 2005 so that Wycor could never again have a chance of winning the contract — even though the award decision itself was never withdrawn — and orders the Lottery to pay the costs, since it was its decision not to perform the contract.
What happened?
The National Lottery launched a general call for tenders for the supply of ‘windmasters and fixed furniture for the sales outlets’, advertised in the Bulletin der Aanbestedingen of 1 August 2003. The contract had two lots: the windmasters, mobile advertising boards, and the fixed furniture. Wyckaert Houtconstructies NV, later Wycor, and Saycom NV each tendered for both lots. On 9 March 2004 the Lottery’s board awarded both lots to Saycom; Wyckaert learned by registered letter of 26 March 2004 that its tender had not been chosen. On 28 May 2004 it sought annulment, limited to lot 2, the fixed furniture. Saycom intervened. After the reply brief, the Lottery’s counsel informed the Council on 3 October 2006 that the Lottery and Saycom had ‘decided to abandon this public contract’, and that Wyckaert therefore no longer had an interest. He enclosed an agreement of 22 June 2005 in which both parties terminated the contract for the production and supply of the permanent furniture. Wyckaert disputed this at length. In reply to a question from the Auditorate, the Lottery confirmed on 20 December 2007 that the award decision ‘was not withdrawn but performance was halted’, and that nothing had ever been delivered under this lot. In its final brief Wycor relied on case law accepting a qualified moral interest even where a contract has already been performed: if that interest survives performance, it argued, then surely it survives where there was never any performance, and the decision still stood. The case was heard only on 14 December 2010. The XIIth chamber, presided over by Dierk Verbiest, with Councillor of State Pierre Barra as rapporteur and a concurring opinion from first auditor Jos Stevens, did not accept that. A rejected bidder’s interest ‘ideally’ lies in once again having at least a chance of being awarded the contract and performing it itself. The decision had admittedly not disappeared from the legal order, but the Lottery had definitively abandoned performance. Wycor would therefore under no circumstances get another chance at the contract. In the specific circumstances the action was inadmissible for lack of a current interest. Because it was the Lottery that decided not to perform the contract, the Council nonetheless ordered it to pay the costs of the action (175 euros); Saycom bears the costs of its intervention (125 euros).
Why does this matter?
The judgment shows a little-discussed way out for a contracting authority facing an action for annulment: not performing the contract. The Lottery did not withdraw its award decision, but together with Saycom halted performance, and that was enough to extinguish the rejected bidder’s interest. The Council draws a clear distinction with the situation where a contract has been performed: there an applicant can sometimes still assert a qualified moral interest, for instance with a view to a damages claim, but Wycor did not succeed in extending that argument to a contract that was never performed. Interest is assessed in practical terms here: will the applicant ever again have a chance at this contract? If not, the debate ends, however irregular the award may have been. The case also illustrates how slow annulment proceedings were at the time: the action dates from May 2004, the termination from June 2005, and the judgment from January 2011. What remains for the applicant is only the costs order: whoever drops the contract pays for the action.
The lesson
For bidders: an action for annulment can take years, and your interest must remain current throughout. Keep track of what the authority does with the contract; if performance is halted, you must show concretely what interest you still have in annulment, for instance with a view to a damages claim or a new procedure, rather than relying on the fact that the decision formally still exists. Consider too whether a faster procedure (suspension) or a damages claim better fits your objective. For contracting authorities: definitively halting a disputed contract can leave an action without purpose, but it is not a free exit; the Council will put the costs on you, and the underlying question of the award’s regularity remains unanswered, including for any civil proceedings. Record such a termination in writing and inform the Council in good time.
Ask yourself
As an applicant bidder, do you still know what is happening with the disputed contract, and have you checked whether it is being performed? If the contract is halted, can you explain concretely what benefit annulment would still bring you? Have you weighed whether a suspension procedure or a damages claim better matches what you want to achieve than an action for annulment that may take years? As a contracting authority, have you recorded the termination of a disputed contract in writing and informed the Council of State? As a contracting authority, are you aware that a termination may put the costs of the action on you and does not answer the question of the award’s regularity?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →