Rejection French-speaking chamber

SOWAER withdraws its 18.9-million-euro sewerage award before the hearing: Colas’s application is inadmissible, but SOWAER pays

Ruling nr. 266892 · 3 June 2026 · VIe kamer

Colas Belgium sought, under extreme urgency, the suspension of SOWAER’s award of the ‘égouttage sud – Rejet R3’ sewerage works to Wanty-TRBA for 18,920,300.78 euros, but SOWAER withdrew that decision six days before the hearing; because the withdrawal is retroactive, Colas could no longer be prejudiced and the application was inadmissible — yet SOWAER, as the losing party, had to bear the 770-euro procedural indemnity and the costs.

What happened?

The Société wallonne des aéroports (SOWAER) put out a public works contract entitled ‘Mise en conformité égouttage sud – Rejet R3’, based on specifications no. SOWAER/TR/CR/780/2025. On 24 April 2026 it awarded the contract to the temporary joint venture Wanty-TRBA for 18,920,300.78 euros excluding VAT. The tender of Colas Belgium SA was found regular and compliant, but was nevertheless set aside. On 12 May 2026 Colas applied for suspension of that decision under extreme urgency; the case was set down for the hearing of 27 May 2026. On 21 May 2026 SOWAER withdrew the contested decision, which it notified to the Council of State on 26 May. The auditor invited Colas to comment at the hearing on whether its application still met the conditions of articles 14 and 15 of the Act of 17 June 2013 after that withdrawal; Colas made no observations. State Councillor Florence Piret, presiding, held that the withdrawal is retroactive to the date of the contested decision. As a result, the alleged infringements, even if proven, had not prejudiced Colas and did not risk doing so. Since that admissibility condition of article 14 was not met, the Council declared the application inadmissible and dismissed it. On costs, the Council looked at the cause of that inadmissibility: it lay in SOWAER’s withdrawal. SOWAER therefore counts as the losing party and Colas as the prevailing party. SOWAER must pay the 200-euro roll fee, the 26-euro contribution and the 770-euro procedural indemnity requested by Colas.

Why does this matter?

The judgment shows a second variant of a scenario that regularly arises in procurement litigation: the contracting authority withdraws its award decision while proceedings are pending. In other judgments (such as 266679 and 266680) an annulment action thereby lost its ‘object’. Here, in extreme-urgency proceedings where the withdrawal came before the hearing, the Council takes a different legal route: because the withdrawal is retroactive, the prejudice that article 14 of the Remedies Act requires as an admissibility condition is missing, and the application is inadmissible. For the unsuccessful bidder the practical result is the same: the award of almost 19 million euros to its competitor is off the table, and the costs stay with the authority. An ‘inadmissible’ in the operative part is therefore no defeat when the authority itself caused that inadmissibility. The judgment says nothing about the substance of Colas’s complaints or the reasons for the withdrawal, nor about what SOWAER does with the contract next.

The lesson

Bidders: an extreme-urgency application creates pressure. If the authority withdraws the award before the hearing, your application becomes inadmissible, but expressly claim the procedural indemnity (here 770 euros): the Council treats the withdrawing authority as the losing party. Then follow the authority’s new decision closely — a withdrawal is not an award to you, and a new decision opens a new time limit for appeal. Contracting authorities: if, after receiving an application, you doubt the lawfulness of your award, a timely withdrawal is a legitimate way to put things right and avoid a ruling on the merits. It is not free, though: roll fee, contribution and procedural indemnity are for your account. The sooner you decide, the lower the litigation costs on both sides.

Ask yourself

Do you know that a withdrawal of the award is retroactive and therefore makes your extreme-urgency application inadmissible, because you can no longer be prejudiced? Did you claim a procedural indemnity in your application, so that the Council can award it if the authority withdraws its decision? Are you following up on what the authority decides after the withdrawal, and do you know the time limit for challenging a new award decision? As a contracting authority: after receiving an application, did you assess the complaints quickly enough to withdraw in time if necessary? As a contracting authority, do you realise that a withdrawal leaves you, as the losing party, bearing the costs and the procedural indemnity?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →