Rejection Dutch-speaking chamber

A second demo for the winner of VRT’s LED-wall contract: unfair according to the losing bidder, but even without those three extra points V. stays ahead

Ruling nr. 267382 · 10 July 2026 · XIIe vakantiekamer

The Council of State refuses, under the extreme-urgency procedure, to suspend the award of VRT’s framework agreement for LED walls to V.: a demo found ‘substandard’ did not mean automatic exclusion because it only lowered the quality score, and the complaint that only V. was allowed a second demo lacks interest because V. remained the most economically advantageous tender even without the three points it gained (85 against 77.61).

What happened?

The Flemish public broadcaster VRT launched a supply contract for a framework agreement on ‘LED-based system screens – design, purchase, delivery and installation’ (reference ‘LED-Walls (2025/OO/602)’), awarded through a competitive procedure with negotiation. To compare tenders objectively, the specifications used three indicative reference packages. The award criteria were total cost of ownership (50 points), quality (40 points) and approach (10 points). Under the specifications, the highest-ranked bidders would give a demonstration after their initial tender. The demo had to show that the solution met the technical requirements and matched the tender — if not, the bid would not be retained — and after the demo ‘the scoring would be re-evaluated’. Fifteen requests to participate and four tenders were received; three bidders gave a demonstration. One participant was placed in the waiting room, partly because its solutions were non-compliant. Negotiations followed with the two remaining bidders, B. BV and V. After the second tenders, V. stood at 85 points (price 50, quality 28, approach 7) and B. at 74.75 (price 38.75, quality 28, approach 8). Because V.’s second tender offered a modified LED-wall model for the Event Space that no longer matched what had been shown at the first demo, VRT had V. give a second demonstration. After the final tenders, V. remained at 85 points while B. rose to 77.61 (price 41.61, quality 28, approach 8). On 8 June 2026 VRT awarded the contract to V. B. went to the Council of State on 23 June 2026. It first asked for confidentiality to be lifted on documents 14 to 47 of the administrative file, in particular the demo evaluations. The Council refused: in an extreme-urgency procedure, without in-depth examination, lifting confidentiality could have irreversible consequences for business secrets, and B. had in any event been able to set out its objections to the second demo at length. In a first plea, B. argued that the award report itself stated that V.’s solution had been ‘considered substandard on a few points during the demo’, so that under the specifications V. should have been excluded or at least placed in the waiting room. The Council disagreed. The demo had a dual role: a compliance check and a re-assessment of the award criteria. The remark appeared in the section ‘Scoring with demo’ and translated into a lower quality score — from 27/40 to 25/40 — rather than a finding of non-compliance. Confidential documents also showed that VRT had in fact checked V.’s technical compliance in detail. An award report need not set out such a regularity review at length when no problems arose. In a second plea, B. complained that only V. was given a second demo, after which its quality score rose from 25/40 to 28/40 with no explanation beyond ‘quality of the solution improved and tested on the basis of new demo’. The Council did the arithmetic: even without those three points V. would have 82 points, still above B.’s 77.61. B. therefore had no interest in that part of the plea. As to equal treatment, B.’s second tender, unlike V.’s, contained no substantial changes, and B. did not show that a second demo of the same solution could have improved its score or ranking. Neither plea was serious; the application was dismissed.

Why does this matter?

Demonstrations and proofs of concept are commonplace in technical supply contracts, and this judgment shows how the Council of State reads them when the specifications give them two functions. A negative remark about a demo is not automatically a finding of non-compliance: where it appears in the award report and what happens to the score determine what it means. A bidder seeking to have a competitor excluded on the strength of a single word such as ‘substandard’ must show that a minimum technical requirement is at stake, not the assessment of an award criterion. Just as instructive is the interest test applied to the second plea. A second demo for one bidder in a negotiated procedure rightly raises questions of equal treatment, but the Council only examines that on the merits if the complaint could change the outcome. Here it simply calculated that V. would have won even without the three disputed points. For contracting authorities the judgment is reassuring, but not unconditionally so: VRT had a concrete reason for the second demo (V. offered a different model from the one shown earlier) and could show in confidential documents that it had examined technical compliance thoroughly. Finally, the judgment confirms that an applicant in extreme-urgency proceedings has little chance of having the confidentiality of evaluation documents lifted, especially when it could formulate its complaints without them.

The lesson

For bidders: before developing a plea, check whether it can actually overturn the ranking. An irregularity worth a few points when the gap is larger does not make a serious plea — you simply have no interest in it. Read a negative evaluation in its context too: if it sits in the scoring section, it concerns quality rather than compliance, and no exclusion follows from it. If you believe a competitor got an advantage you did not, show concretely what you could have gained from it. For contracting authorities: if you give one bidder an extra demo, record the reason (here: a changed model in the second tender) and justify the resulting score change with more than a single sentence. Keep the compliance check and the re-assessment of the award criteria clearly separate in the specifications, and document the technical regularity review in the file, even if the award report does not go into detail.

Ask yourself

As a bidder, have you calculated whether your complaint, even if well founded, could close the points gap with the selected bidder? Can you show that a ‘substandard’ demo concerns a minimum technical requirement, and not just the score on an award criterion? Do you make it concretely plausible what an extra demonstration or negotiation round would have gained you? As a contracting authority, do your specifications clearly distinguish the compliance check during a demo from the re-assessment of the award criteria? As a contracting authority, have you recorded in writing the reason for an additional demonstration for one bidder, and the score change that follows from it?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →