Sogeplant challenges the motorway green-maintenance contract but fails to turn up: extreme-urgency application dismissed without a word on the merits
Sogeplant sought the suspension under extreme urgency of SOFICO’s decision of 22 June 2026 to declare its tender for the maintenance of motorway green spaces irregular and to award lot 1 to Krinkels for EUR 1,036,366.03 excluding VAT, but because it was neither present nor represented at the hearing of 28 July 2026, the Council of State dismissed the application under article 11 of the royal decree of 19 November 2024, without examining the pleas.
What happened?
The Société wallonne de financement complémentaire des infrastructures (SOFICO) put out a works contract entitled ‘Bail de brossage, curage, propreté, d’entretien des espaces verts autoroutiers’. Lot 1 covered the maintenance of the green spaces along the motorways. By a decision of 22 June 2026, SOFICO declared the tender of Sogeplant SA irregular, awarded the lot to Krinkels for EUR 1,036,366.03 excluding VAT and decided not to award it to Sogeplant. On 7 July 2026 Sogeplant filed an application for suspension under extreme urgency and for annulment of that decision. By an order of 8 July 2026 the procedural timetable was set and the case was listed for the hearing of 28 July 2026. SOFICO filed its observations and the administrative file on time, and the contribution and fees were paid. At the hearing only SOFICO’s lawyers appeared; Sogeplant, although duly summoned, was neither present nor represented. The president of the VIth vacation chamber, State Councillor Florence Piret, recalled that article 25, first paragraph, of the law of 17 June 2013 refers, for procedure, to the rules of the review body, and that article 11 of the royal decree of 19 November 2024 provides that all parties must be present or represented and that the application for suspension is dismissed if the applicant is not. Since the law of 17 June 2013 does not derogate from this, the application had to be dismissed; Deputy Auditor-General Éric Thibaut advised to the same effect. What SOFICO considered irregular in Sogeplant’s tender, and what Sogeplant argued against it, is not discussed in the judgment. The Council did, in the absence of any objection, maintain the confidentiality of exhibits 2 and 4 to the application, of exhibits 2.1.1 to 2.3.1 of the administrative file and of two documents that SOFICO had lodged confidentially on the electronic platform on 27 July 2026 at the request of the Deputy Auditor-General. Costs were reserved.
Why does this matter?
Since the new interim-relief rules of 19 November 2024, attendance at the hearing is no longer a formality: an applicant who stays away automatically loses its application for suspension, however strong its pleas may be. This judgment shows how short that process is — three pages, not a single consideration on the irregularity of the tender, and an award worth over one million euros that simply remains enforceable. For a bidder that drafts an application at extreme speed, incurs the costs and pays the fees, that is a painful outcome, especially in the summer months, when the case comes before a vacation chamber and the hearing follows quickly. The judgment rules only on suspension: the annulment action remains pending and costs are reserved. It also shows that the confidentiality of documents does not automatically fall away with the application for suspension — the Council keeps them confidential ‘at this stage of the proceedings’. Notably, the roles are reversed compared to judgment no. 261.260: there it was Krinkels that lost an application for suspension against SOFICO by default; here Krinkels is the successful tenderer.
The lesson
If you file an application for suspension under extreme urgency, enter the hearing date from the order immediately in your lawyer’s diary and your company’s, and make sure someone appears — even in July or August. An application alone is not enough: without attendance or representation it is dismissed, without your grievances being examined. If you no longer wish to proceed, arrange that explicitly and still be represented, so that you keep control over how the case is wound up. If you are a contracting authority, be represented as well when you suspect the other side will not come: your attendance is equally mandatory, and it allows you to defend your position on confidentiality and costs. And remember that a dismissed suspension does not end the annulment action — the award can still be challenged on the merits.
Ask yourself
Do you know the date of the hearing and who will represent you there, even if it falls during the summer recess? Do you realise that the new interim-relief rules make an absent applicant automatically lose its application for suspension, without the Council looking at the merits? If you want to withdraw, have you clearly arranged your discontinuance and the costs in advance? Have you expressly marked your confidential documents as confidential? And as a contracting authority: have you arranged your representation at the hearing, even if you expect the applicant not to appear?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →