No signed tender form, no tender: Think Media Outdoor loses Auderghem’s street-furniture contract to JC Decaux because the ‘model’ at the back of the specifications turned out to be mandatory
Think Media Outdoor submitted a detailed tender to the municipality of Auderghem for street furniture with advertising panels, but without the tender form attached as a ‘modèle de soumission’ at the back of the specifications, and the Council of State held that the municipality could declare the tender irregular because it nowhere contained the general undertaking to perform the contract ‘on its own movable and immovable property’ in accordance with the specifications — while the social-security debts of the winner, JC Decaux, stayed below the EUR 2,500 threshold.
What happened?
The municipality of Auderghem put out an open call for tenders for the supply, installation and maintenance of street furniture — planimeters with poster displays. In return for the advertising rights, bidders offered the municipality a fee. The specifications were approved by the municipal council on 17 December 2009 and the notice appeared in the Belgian Tender Bulletin on 8 February 2010. Article 8 of the specifications listed the documents to be enclosed: graphic presentations, a technical report on strength and protection against vandalism, corrosion and graffiti, a note on the calculation of the fee and a note on the proposed contract term. At the back of the specifications was a ‘tender form’ — in the French version a ‘modèle de soumission’ — in which the bidder undertook ‘on its own movable and immovable property’ to perform the contract in accordance with the specifications for a fee to be filled in. The specifications nowhere referred to that form and did not expressly require its use. On 31 May 2010 three tenders were opened: from Think Media Outdoor, Clear Channel Belgium and JC Decaux Belgium Publicité. On 20 July 2010 the municipal executive selected all three. It noted that JC Decaux owed social-security contributions but did not exclude it because there was no withholding obligation for its customers. Think Media Outdoor’s tender, by contrast, was declared irregular: it contained no tender form, so there was no ‘legal title’ giving certainty about its legal undertaking and performance guarantees. The tenders of Clear Channel and JC Decaux were found regular; JC Decaux was ranked first and won the contract. Think Media Outdoor received the decision by registered letter posted only on 9 August 2010 and applied for suspension under the extreme-urgency procedure on 24 August 2010. Its first plea targeted JC Decaux: a bidder with social-security debts should have been excluded, or the municipality should at least have explained why not. The Council noted that the social-security certificate enclosed with JC Decaux’s tender stated that on 13 April 2010 it had filed all returns up to the fourth quarter of 2009 and owed no more than EUR 2,500 in contributions. It therefore did not fall within the exclusion ground of Article 43(2)(5) and could not be excluded. That the reasoning gave a different reason was irrelevant: Think Media Outdoor had no interest in that criticism. The second plea concerned its own tender. Think Media Outdoor argued that a ‘model’ not made mandatory anywhere in the specifications or notice could not justify exclusion, that its tender — signed by the managing director — contained all requested documents and, in section 7, a detailed description of its undertakings, and that it was contradictory to select it first and then exclude it. The Council disagreed. Under Article 89 of the Royal Decree of 8 January 1996, the bidder draws up its tender on the form attached to the specifications or declares on any other document that it conforms to the model; that requirement applies even if the specifications do not repeat it. Section 7 of the tender described the term, the planimeters and the fee, but Think Media Outdoor did not show where the general undertaking ‘on its own property’ appeared. Moreover, several provisions of the specifications were missing or incompletely reproduced: conformity and unavoidable measures, the complementary furniture in the maintenance obligations, the municipality’s right to have indecent posters removed, the indexation clause and the penalties. The municipality could thus consider that there was insufficient certainty about the undertaking. Selection and regularity are two different tests; a selected bidder may well submit an irregular tender. The application was dismissed. JC Decaux bears the costs of its intervention, EUR 125.
Why does this matter?
The judgment shows how much weight a seemingly formal document can carry. The tender form is not just an administrative sheet: it is where the bidder commits unconditionally, with all its assets, to perform the contract in accordance with the specifications. If it is missing, the tender must contain that undertaking fully and unambiguously in some other way — and a self-drafted description of the services that omits or incompletely reproduces certain clauses does not do so. The Council makes clear that the obligation to use the form follows from the regulations themselves, even if the specifications do not repeat it and call the form a ‘model’. The judgment also confirms two points that still hold: a bidder with a small social-security debt below the statutory threshold cannot be excluded, and criticism of deficient reasoning achieves nothing if the decision is substantively correct.
The lesson
For bidders: always use the tender form attached to the specifications, complete it fully and have it signed by someone who can bind the company — even if the specifications call it a ‘model’ and it is not on the list of mandatory annexes. If you do use your own document, expressly declare that it conforms to the model and reproduce the undertaking verbatim. An extensive self-drafted description of your services is no substitute: rephrasing clauses of the specifications risks leaving some out. Check before submission that your social-security and tax certificates are in order, and know that a competitor with a small arrear below the threshold cannot be excluded. For contracting authorities: refer expressly in the specifications to the tender form and state that it must be used; that avoids disputes. Base a decision to exclude or not to exclude on the correct legal ground — here the EUR 2,500 threshold — and not on a side argument.
Ask yourself
Did you use the tender form from the specifications, complete it fully and have it signed by a person who can bind your company? If you work with your own document, does your tender contain an express declaration that it conforms to the model, and the full undertaking to perform the contract in accordance with the specifications? Are you reproducing clauses of the specifications in your own words, and if so, have you checked that none is missing or less complete than in the specifications? Do you know which threshold applies to social-security or tax debts before a competitor can be excluded? As a contracting authority: do your specifications expressly state that the tender form must be used, and is your decision on an exclusion ground based on the correct statutory threshold?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →