‘Robbrecht and Daem will design it’ is not a tender: Clear Channel offered Bruges a luxury bus shelter that did not yet exist and was rightly excluded
When Clear Channel Belgium filled in the mandatory luxury bus-shelter type for the Bruges tender with nothing more than a promise that the architects Robbrecht and Daem would, after the award and in consultation with the city, design a shelter ‘at least equivalent’ to its standard ECOline model, the city of Bruges was entitled to treat the tender as incomplete and void, and the Council of State dismissed the extreme-urgency application — even though only one bidder, J.C. Decaux, remained.
What happened?
In May 2010 the city of Bruges launched an EU-advertised general call for tenders for the supply, installation and maintenance of bus-stop shelters (special specifications ‘Mobiliteit 02’). The specifications required every bidder, ‘on pain of nullity of the tender’, to offer two types: a standard three-walled shelter for most stops, and a luxury type for specific projects or locations, to be installed at the city’s direction. The first award criterion — overall concept, quality and materials, weight 30 — was assessed per type (15 points for type 1, 15 for type 2), and bidders had to enclose ‘all documents allowing an assessment against criterion 1 (drawings, technical description, photos, etc.)’. The second criterion was the annual fee. At the opening on 24 June 2010 there were two tenders: Clear Channel Belgium’s and J.C. Decaux’s. Clear Channel proposed its ECOline model as the standard type, fully documented with photos, drawings and technical specifications. For the luxury type, however, it wrote that rather than a ‘luxury version’ of the ECOline it preferred ‘a specific design’ for each location: the architects Robbrecht and Daem — known for the Bruges Concert Hall — would, after the award, design stop infrastructure for Bruges with full input from the city, and the materials and user comfort would be ‘at least equivalent’ to those of the ECOline. Photos of the firm’s projects were interspersed. On 13 August 2010 the college of mayor and aldermen declared the tender void: for the luxury type there were no materials, dimensions, photos or drawings, and the city had asked for a concrete design, not a proposal to devise one together later. On 31 August 2010 Clear Channel applied for suspension under the extreme-urgency procedure. The Council of State first noted that the contract had been advertised after 24 February 2010, so the new remedies regime of the Act of 23 December 2009 applied: serious and irreparable harm no longer had to be shown, only a serious plea. That was lacking. For type 2 the tender contained only generalities and a promise of equivalence, not a concrete description. The open-ended specifications, the absence of quantities and locations for the luxury shelters and their installation ‘at the city’s direction’ did not alter the fact that a concrete proposal was required, not an offer to have the type designed after the award. The photos did not help either: the city produced an e-mail from Robbrecht & Daem confirming that Clear Channel had merely asked for a portfolio of ‘various small free-standing projects, pavilions’, including an existing bus canopy next to the Concert Hall as a reference, and that the firm had never been asked to prepare a preliminary design. The proportionality argument also failed: the fact that only one bidder remained after the exclusion does not oblige a contracting authority to accept a tender that does not meet the specifications. And the investment needed to develop a luxury model is, the Council held, inherent in tendering — J.C. Decaux had in fact submitted a concrete proposal. The application was dismissed; Clear Channel bears the costs of EUR 175.
Why does this matter?
The judgment draws a clear line between a tender and a statement of intent. Where the specifications announce a separate assessment of concept, quality and materials for each type and ask for drawings, descriptions and photos to that end, the bidder must submit something assessable for each type. A reference to a renowned designer, a promise of consultation and an ‘at least equivalent to our standard model’ clause are not a description: they leave the contracting authority nothing to score and turn the award into a blank cheque. The judgment is also instructive on two arguments bidders often raise. Open-ended specifications do not relieve a bidder of the duty to make a concrete proposal — they leave room to choose something concrete oneself. And the loss of competition when only two bidders remain is no reason to admit an incomplete tender. Finally, it shows how the contracting authority could undermine the tender’s credibility with a single e-mail from the named architects: anyone who features partners in a tender must be able to substantiate their commitment.
The lesson
Where the specifications ask, per type or lot, for documents to assess an award criterion, submit a concrete, assessable proposal for each type — with drawings, dimensions, materials and photos — even if you believe bespoke design after the award would be better. That view belongs in a variant or a question before submission, not in place of what is required. Do not name designers or partners in your tender whose commitment you do not have in writing, and do not use portfolio photos that do not show what you are offering. For contracting authorities: state expressly, as Bruges did, which documents must be submitted for each type and what sanction applies if they are missing; you can then exclude an incomplete tender even if only one bidder remains. Give concrete reasons for the exclusion — exactly what is missing — so the decision withstands review under the duty to state substantive reasons.
Ask yourself
Does your tender contain, for each required type or lot, the documents listed in the specifications for assessing the award criteria? Do you describe concretely what you will supply, or mainly promise something that will only be designed after the award? Can you substantiate in writing the commitment of the partners and designers you name in your tender? Did you raise any objection to the design of the specifications in good time before submission, rather than trying to resolve it in your tender? As a contracting authority: do your specifications state expressly which documents must be submitted per type and on pain of what sanction?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →