Rejection French-speaking chamber

A 124-million-euro PPP police headquarters in Charleroi: Moury-Wust trips over the transitional rules and its own articles of association — but the city pays the costs, because it cited the wrong remedies

Ruling nr. 210299 · 7 January 2011 · VIe kamer

The Council of State dismisses the extremely urgent application by the temporary partnership Moury-Wust against the award of Charleroi’s new police headquarters to CFE, because two directors of Moury had no power to decide on the action on their own and because the contract had been advertised before 25 February 2010, so that the old regime still applied and the applicants had to show serious harm that would be difficult to repair rather than rely on the balance of interests under the new Act — although the Council orders the city to pay the costs, since its own notification had referred to the new rules.

What happened?

The city of Charleroi wanted to have a new police headquarters built for the Charleroi police zone through a contractual public-private partnership, together with a rehearsal hall for the choreographic centre Charleroi Danses, on the Caserne Defeld site on boulevard Mayence. The contractor was to design, build and pre-finance the project and then maintain the building for 25 years; the city would pay 15,000,000 euros on provisional acceptance and the balance in equal instalments. Specifications CONC-CONS-FIN-HDB/2009 described it as a promotion contract with additional services. The contract notice appeared in the Bulletin der Aanbestedingen on 9 October 2009, with an estimated value of 50,000,000 euros excluding VAT and the following award criteria: price (40%), quality of the preliminary design (35%), the SLA (10%), the time to delivery (10%) and project management (5%). Three corrigenda followed: the one of 28 December 2009 refined the rating requirement for the financial institution and postponed the submission date, while those of 28 April and 16 June 2010 pushed back the opening of tenders further, ultimately to 1 September 2010. According to the applicants, a second version of the specifications was also published on 1 June 2010. Four tenders were received: from the temporary partnership Moury-Wust, from Dexia Bank, from CFE and from the association Koeckelberg-Louis De Waele-Franki. In its report of 28 October 2010 the committee found that Moury-Wust and the Koeckelberg association did not meet all the technical capacity criteria. A supplementary report of 15 November 2010 noted that missing information had been provided in time, but confirmed only the selection of Dexia Bank and CFE. On 30 November 2010 the city executive awarded the contract to CFE for 124,057,144 euros excluding VAT. The registered notification of 10 December 2010 expressly referred to the new Book IIbis of the Act of 24 December 1993 (Articles 65/14 and 65/15) and stated that an action could be brought before the Council of State. Moury-Wust filed an extremely urgent application on 23 December 2010 and, to be safe, applied the same day to the president of the Charleroi court of first instance under the old Article 21bis. At the hearing its counsel asked the Council to record a discontinuance, but only in case the new Act turned out not to apply. Councillor of State Paul Lewalle, acting president of the VIth chamber, refused that conditional discontinuance: the applicants had deliberately chosen the new Act, and determining whether the condition was met required the application to be examined in any event. On standing, he held that the temporary partnership has no legal personality, so all its members must act jointly and regularly in court. The city’s argument that Bemat SA should also have joined failed: nothing showed that Bemat had submitted a tender or was part of the partnership. For Wust everything was in order: Article 18 of its articles of association allowed two directors jointly to represent the company in court. Moury was a different matter. The decision to bring an extremely urgent application is not an act of day-to-day management and was therefore for the board of directors. Article 18 of its articles merely allowed two directors to sign ‘acts’ and ‘powers of attorney’ binding the company; that is a delegation of signing authority, not a power to decide on litigation, and not a representation clause within the meaning of Article 522(2) of the Companies Code. Prima facie the application was therefore inadmissible. On the substance, too, it failed. The contract had essentially been advertised on 9 October 2009; the corrigenda had only clarified a selection requirement and moved dates. The new remedies regime of the Act of 23 December 2009 entered into force only on 25 February 2010, and under Article 7, second paragraph, of that Act this contract remained subject to the rules in force on the date of the notice. That meant the old Article 21bis and Article 17(2) of the coordinated Acts: serious grounds and serious harm that would be difficult to repair. Moury-Wust had relied entirely on the balance of interests under the new Article 65/15, arguing that a suspension would delay performance by a few weeks at most. It had thus not shown serious harm, and the pleas about its exclusion at selection were not even examined. The Council did acknowledge that the city’s incorrect notification had ‘probably misled’ the applicants. That did not entitle them to the new regime, but it was reason enough to order the city to pay the costs of 350 euros.

Why does this matter?

The judgment falls in the middle of the transitional period after the reform of remedies in public procurement, and shows how sharp that line was. For contracts advertised after 24 February 2010, a serious plea sufficed in an extremely urgent application against an award, and the Council could weigh the interests. For contracts advertised before that date, the classic interim procedure still applied, with the requirement of serious harm that would be difficult to repair. What counts is the date of the original contract notice: corrigenda that merely shift deadlines do not turn an old contract into a new one. In a PPP file that drags on for more than a year, as here, that difference can still matter long after the new Act entered into force. The lesson on standing is just as instructive: a clause allowing two directors to sign ‘acts’ and ‘powers of attorney’ is not the same as a clause allowing them to represent the company in court. Wust had such a clause, Moury did not, and because a temporary partnership has no legal personality, the defect of one member brought down the whole application. Finally, the judgment says something about the contracting authority’s responsibility: an incorrect statement of remedies in the notification does not change the applicable law, but it can determine who bears the costs.

The lesson

For bidders: in any dispute, look first at the date of the original contract notice, not at the award notification; that date determines which remedies regime applies, and a notification can be wrong. If in doubt, argue both tracks in your application: also set out concrete serious harm instead of staking everything on a balance of interests. Before going to the Council, check who in your company — and in each member of a temporary partnership — has the power to decide on litigation, and when in doubt let the board itself decide; the deadline in an extremely urgent procedure leaves no room to fix this afterwards. For contracting authorities: state in the notification of the award decision the remedies that actually apply. An incorrect statement will not rescue the applicant, but you will bear the costs of the confusion you cause.

Ask yourself

As a bidder, do you know the date on which the contract was originally advertised, and which remedies regime follows from it? Do you distinguish between a corrigendum that merely moves deadlines and a new contract notice? Does your application demonstrate concrete serious harm that would be difficult to repair where the old regime may apply? Under the articles of association of each member of your temporary partnership, do the people deciding to go to the Council of State have the power to decide on litigation, and not merely signing authority? As a contracting authority, does your notification state the remedies and time limits that actually apply to this contract?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →