‘Borrowing’ a class 6 accreditation from Cordeel after the fact: Council of State suspends award of Fedasil housing modules in Jodoigne
The Federal Buildings Agency awarded lot 7 of a contract for prefabricated housing modules for asylum seekers in Jodoigne to Eagle Construct, even though it lacked the required class 6 accreditation and only after the opening of tenders, at the Agency’s request, put forward Cordeel as a subcontractor holding the necessary accreditation — the Council of State saw this as a serious breach of the duty of care and suspended the award at the request of De Meeuw.
What happened?
The Federal Buildings Agency (Regie der Gebouwen) put out, by public tender, a works contract for the manufacture, delivery, installation and connection of prefabricated housing modules for Fedasil, intended to house asylum seekers, on eight sites, each with its own lot (specifications no. 2010/Arch/01). The contract was estimated at between EUR 5.5 and 6.5 million excluding VAT and was published at European level in April 2010. For lot 7 in Jodoigne, the notice and the specifications required accreditation in category D or F, class 6. Four bidders tendered for that lot, including De Meeuw and Eagle Construct. On 16 June 2010 the Agency pointed out to Eagle Construct that it did not hold class 6 and asked for proof that an accreditation application had been filed before the opening of tenders on 18 May 2010. Eagle Construct replied that it had understood lot 7 to consist of two sub-lots (7 and 7A), each within the class 5 limit, and that it could if necessary provide the higher class through a partner it regularly worked with. On 2 July 2010 the Agency confirmed that class 6 was required and asked for proof that a subcontractor held the accreditation and undertook to actually perform the contract. On 12 July 2010 Eagle Construct supplied Cordeel’s accreditation certificate (class 8) and a statement of 9 July 2010, signed by a commercial director, in which Cordeel undertook ‘to perform the contract as subcontractor’ and to make all necessary resources available. On 10 December 2010 the Minister of Finance excluded Jan Snel for insufficient accreditation (class 4) and awarded lot 7 to Eagle Construct. De Meeuw, informed on 14 December 2010, applied on 24 December 2010 for suspension under extreme urgency. Because the contract had been published after 24 February 2010, the new remedies regime of the law of 23 December 2009 applied: serious harm that is difficult to repair no longer had to be shown, only a serious plea. The Council found the second plea serious. A bidder who wishes to rely on a subcontractor for accreditation must, under articles 18 to 20 and 90 of the royal decree of 8 January 1996, show that it will have that subcontractor’s resources at its disposal, and must name the subcontractor and its accreditation in the tender itself. Eagle Construct’s tender did not mention Cordeel anywhere: the tender form left the section on subcontractors and the value of subcontracted work blank, and Cordeel did not appear on the list of seven subcontractors included elsewhere in the tender. Cordeel only appeared once the accreditation problem arose, without any indication of which part of the contract it would perform. The Agency had not examined that undertaking concretely and had merely noted in the award report that proof had been provided. The accreditation requirement would be entirely hollowed out, the Council said, if a bidder could put forward another company as subcontractor after the fact without the undertaking being tested and without it being clear what it covered. The Council did not suspend the implicit decision not to award the contract to De Meeuw: the defect was a lack of care, and the outcome of a fresh examination was not certain. Eagle Construct asked the Council to refrain from suspension given the urgent need to house asylum seekers, but the Council saw no reason to do so: it concerned one of nine lots, the contract was only one of several initiatives, a new decision on the existing tenders could follow quickly, and the Agency itself, which represents the public interest, had not asked for a balancing of interests. The award of lot 7 was suspended; Eagle Construct bore the 125-euro cost of its intervention.
Why does this matter?
The judgment dates from 2011 and applies the royal decree of 8 January 1996, but its core remains relevant: a bidder that does not itself meet an accreditation or selection requirement may rely on the capacities of a third party, but this must be apparent from the tender, with a concrete undertaking from that third party. What the Council condemns here is the pattern in which a bidder fixes the problem only after the opening of tenders by putting forward a partner — at the invitation of the authority itself. Such after-the-fact regularisation affects equal treatment: the other bidders did have to hold or demonstrate the accreditation when tendering. The judgment also places responsibility on the authority: a statement by a commercial director that does not say which part of the works the subcontractor will perform is not proof that can simply be ticked off. It further shows how the then-new remedies regime worked: no more proof of serious harm, but a balancing of interests in which an intervening party’s appeal to the public interest carried little weight as long as the authority itself did not invoke it. For today’s bidders, the same logic is reflected in reliance on third-party capacities under the law of 17 June 2016.
The lesson
For bidders: if you do not yourself hold the required accreditation class, state in your tender which subcontractor you rely on, attach its accreditation and a signed, concrete undertaking, and indicate which part and what value of the works it will perform. Read the notice and specifications carefully: here the successful bidder thought lot 7 consisted of two class 5 sub-lots, which was not the case. And as an unsuccessful bidder: check in the award report and the file how the authority assessed the successful bidder’s accreditation and when that evidence came in. For authorities: do not let a bidder cure a missing accreditation after the opening of tenders with a new subcontractor, and do not tick off a third-party undertaking without examining who signed it and exactly what it covers. If you want to avoid a suspension on public-interest grounds, you must request and substantiate that balancing yourself.
Ask yourself
Do you yourself hold the accreditation class required for the lot you are bidding on, and have you read the class per lot in the notice correctly? If not: is the subcontractor you rely on named in your tender, with its accreditation, share and value, and is its signed undertaking attached? Is that undertaking signed by someone who can bind the company, and does it state which part of the works it will perform? As an authority: did you assess the successful bidder’s accreditation on the basis of what was in the tender, or did you allow missing elements to be supplied afterwards? And if you wish to rely on the public interest to avoid a suspension, have you raised and substantiated it yourself?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →