Proximus drops its annulment action against the Walloon cyber framework agreement, but the Agence du Numérique pays: an authority that withdraws its award remains the losing party
After the Council of State had dismissed the application by Proximus and Proximus NXT IT to suspend the award of a Walloon framework agreement for cyber-incident response to the NRB consortium — because the Agence du Numérique had meanwhile withdrawn that award — the applicants did not ask for the proceedings to continue, so the Council recorded the discontinuance; since the authority had withdrawn its own decision, it still had to bear the EUR 770 procedural indemnity, the EUR 400 court fee and the EUR 26 contribution.
What happened?
On 20 November 2025 the board of the Agence du Numérique (AdN), a public-law company, awarded a services framework agreement for an operational team providing 24/7 on-site response to cyber incidents across Wallonia to the consortium represented by Network Research Belgium (NRB), and declared the tender of Proximus and Proximus NXT IT irregular. On 12 December 2025 both companies brought an action for annulment together with an application for suspension in extreme urgency. On 18 December 2025 the AdN withdrew the contested award. By judgment no. 265.347 of 8 January 2026 the Council dismissed the suspension application, since the alleged illegalities could no longer harm the applicants. Proximus then filed no request to continue the proceedings within thirty days of notification of that judgment. First auditor Constantin Nikis asked on 18 February 2026 for the simplified procedure of Article 11/3 of the general rules of procedure, and on 25 February 2026 the registry informed the applicants that the chamber would record the discontinuance unless they asked to be heard within fifteen days. They did not. On 9 July 2026 Xavier Close, acting president of the VIth chamber, applied the statutory presumption of discontinuance under Article 17(10) of the coordinated laws. On costs, he held that by withdrawing the contested act the AdN was the unsuccessful party within the meaning of Article 30/1, and ordered it to bear the court fee (EUR 400), the contribution (EUR 26) and the procedural indemnity of EUR 770 (base amount).
Why does this matter?
The case had in substance been settled by the withdrawal itself: six days after the action was filed, the AdN withdrew its award, allowing suspension judgment no. 265.347 to dismiss the application without examining the pleas. Pursuing the annulment of an act that no longer existed made no sense, so the applicants let the presumption of discontinuance take effect. Doing so cost them nothing: the Council links costs not to who drops the case, but to who removed the cause of the dispute. Withdrawal of the contested act counts as an acknowledgement that the applicants were right to sue — in line with settled case law that an authority withdrawing its award after an action is the losing party for costs purposes.
The lesson
Tenderers: if the authority withdraws the contested award, you need not invest further in annulment proceedings; you can let the case lapse through the presumption of discontinuance — but do claim a procedural indemnity expressly in your application so the Council can grant it at closure. Keep watching the authority’s next decision: a new award requires a fresh, timely challenge. Contracting authorities: withdrawal is a legitimate way to correct a disputed award, but expect to bear the costs, even if the applicant does nothing further.
Ask yourself
Did you claim a procedural indemnity in your application, so it can be awarded even on discontinuance? Do you know that you must file a request to continue within thirty days of notification of a judgment dismissing suspension if you want to pursue annulment? After a withdrawal, are you following what the authority does next and ready to challenge a new decision? And as an authority: have you factored in the cost impact of withdrawing an award after an action?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →