Karsan v. the Walloon transport operator: suspended bus award withdrawn, action without object — and one procedural indemnity, not two
After the Council of State had suspended the award of lot 2 of the Walloon framework agreement for electric buses to Iveco Belgium, the Opérateur de Transport de Wallonie definitively withdrew that decision, so Karsan’s action for annulment lost its object, the suspension was lifted and the OTW, as the losing party, had to pay the costs and a single procedural indemnity of 770 euros.
What happened?
On 5 December 2025 the Opérateur de Transport de Wallonie (OTW) awarded lot 2 of the framework agreement ‘Supply of a public transport solution with standard and articulated electric buses’ to Iveco Belgium SA. The Turkish bus manufacturer Karsan Otomotiv sought annulment of that award on 19 January 2026. By judgment no. 265.629 of 30 January 2026 the Council of State admitted Iveco Belgium as intervening party and suspended the award decision. Normally a simple outcome follows: if the defending party or the beneficiary does not ask, within thirty days of notification of the suspension judgment, for the proceedings to continue, the Council may annul the suspended act (Article 17, § 9, of the coordinated laws). Neither the OTW nor Iveco Belgium filed such a request, and on 6 March 2026 the first auditor asked for that simplified procedure to be applied. In the meantime, however, the OTW had itself withdrawn the contested decision on 13 February 2026. The withdrawal was notified to the bidders by e-mail and registered letter on 17 February 2026, stating the available remedies, forms and time limits. No one challenged it in time, so the withdrawal became final and the action lost its object. As to costs, Karsan had claimed a procedural indemnity of 770 euros both in its suspension application and in its application for annulment. The Council held that the withdrawal made the OTW the losing party and Karsan the successful party, but that Karsan put forward nothing to justify a double indemnity. The 20% increase that is sometimes available was also excluded because the contested act had been withdrawn (Article 67, § 2, third paragraph, of the general rules of procedure). The Council ruled that there was no longer any need to adjudicate, lifted the suspension ordered by judgment no. 265.629 and ordered the OTW to pay the 200-euro court fee, the 26-euro contribution and the 770-euro procedural indemnity. Iveco Belgium bears the 150-euro fee for its intervention.
Why does this matter?
The judgment shows the usual end stage of a successful suspension in procurement litigation: the contracting authority withdraws its award and the annulment action loses its object. The sequence is interesting. The OTW could have let the simplified annulment procedure of Article 17, § 9, run its course, but withdrew the decision itself before the time limit for a request to continue had expired. As a result there is no annulment judgment, but the cost outcome is still that of a losing party. On two points the judgment also sets limits for applicants. Seeking both suspension and annulment does not automatically yield two procedural indemnities: without concrete justification, it remains a single basic amount of 770 euros. And the 20% increase that the rules of procedure allow in certain cases falls away once the act has been withdrawn. Finally, the Council confirms that a withdrawal only ends the action once it is final: properly notified to all bidders, stating the available remedies, and not challenged in time.
The lesson
For bidders: a suspension followed by a withdrawal is in practice a win — the award is gone — and the costs are recovered from the contracting authority. Do not count on a double procedural indemnity for suspension and annulment, though: that must be concretely substantiated, and the 20% increase is excluded after a withdrawal. Also keep an eye on the withdrawal decision itself: it is a new act with its own time limits for appeal. For contracting authorities: withdrawing a suspended award is a legitimate way to put the procurement right, but notify the withdrawal to all bidders with the remedies, forms and time limits so that it becomes final. Expect to bear the costs as the losing party; the intervening beneficiary pays only its own intervention fee.
Ask yourself
Do you know that the Council may annul a suspended award if the contracting authority or the beneficiary does not request continuation of the proceedings within thirty days? As an applicant, do you have a concrete reason to claim two procedural indemnities for suspension and annulment — or are you silently expecting two? Are you aware that the 20% increase of the procedural indemnity falls away if the contested act is withdrawn? As a contracting authority: have you notified the withdrawal to all bidders, stating the remedies, forms and time limits? As an unsuccessful bidder, have you followed up the withdrawal decision and the further course of the procurement?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →