Water-Link withdraws the award of its distribution-network framework agreement before the hearing: application without object, but Water-Link pays the costs
After an unsuccessful bidder sought suspension, under the extreme-urgency procedure, of the award of both lots of Water-Link’s ‘Framework agreement for distribution network works’, Water-Link withdrew that award before the first scheduled hearing; the Council of State dismissed the application and, applying Article 30, § 5, also the action for annulment, but ordered Water-Link to pay the costs, including a 770-euro procedural indemnity.
What happened?
On 28 May 2026 Water-Link decided to award both lots of the public works contract ‘Framework agreement for distribution network works’ to another bidder, and therefore not to award lot 2 to G. BV. On 15 June 2026 G. BV filed a single application seeking both suspension under the extreme-urgency procedure and annulment of the award of lot 1, of lot 2 and of the decision not to award lot 2 to it. The hearing was first set for 1 July 2026. On 25 June 2026 Water-Link withdrew the contested decision of 28 May 2026 awarding both lots to the other bidder. At the hearing of 9 July 2026 only counsel for the applicant appeared. The Council held that the application had thereby lost its object in its entirety and was therefore inadmissible — including in so far as it was directed against the implicit decision not to award lot 2 to the applicant. Since suspension and annulment had been sought in a single application, the Council applied Article 30, § 5, of the coordinated laws: the action for annulment shared the same fate and was also dismissed. The Council nevertheless ordered Water-Link to bear the costs of the application: a court fee of 200 euros, a contribution of 26 euros and a procedural indemnity of 770 euros payable to the applicant. First auditor and head of division Ann Eylenbosch delivered a concurring opinion.
Why does this matter?
The judgment is short, but shows clearly how a quickly withdrawn award closes extreme-urgency proceedings. Water-Link withdrew its decision within ten days of the application and before the first scheduled hearing. For the applicant that is a practical win — the award to the competitor is gone — even though the judgment is formally a ‘dismissal’. Two points stand out. First, the withdrawal of the award also removes the implicit decision not to select the applicant: the Council does not treat it as a separate surviving issue. Second, choosing a single application for suspension and annulment has a consequence: under Article 30, § 5, the annulment action is dismissed at the same time, so the case is closed in one go. That the costs and procedural indemnity are nonetheless borne by Water-Link confirms the line that a contracting authority that withdraws its decision after it has been challenged bears the costs of those proceedings.
The lesson
For bidders: an extreme-urgency application can achieve its aim without any judgment on the merits. If the contracting authority withdraws the award, the contested award is gone and your court fee, contribution and procedural indemnity are recovered from the authority, even though the application is formally dismissed. Be aware that with a single application the annulment action also falls away immediately: if you want to challenge the further course of the procurement, you must do so against the new decision. For contracting authorities: if on reflection you see a problem in your award decision, a quick withdrawal can keep the proceedings short, but it does not spare you the applicant’s costs.
Ask yourself
As a bidder: do you know that withdrawal of the award by the contracting authority deprives your extreme-urgency application of its object, but that the costs and procedural indemnity can then be borne by the authority? Did you deliberately opt for a single application for suspension and annulment, and do you know the consequence of Article 30, § 5, if the application is dismissed? Are you following up the new decision the authority takes after the withdrawal, with its own time limit for appeal? As a contracting authority: when your award is challenged, have you quickly assessed whether a withdrawal is appropriate — knowing that you will bear the costs of the proceedings?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →