No Recupel membership, yet no irregular tender: the Federal Justice Service may order 610 fridges for the new Antwerp prison from the cheapest bidder
W. BV, which came second with 80.69 against 85.69 points for 610 tabletop fridges for the new Antwerp prison, failed in its urgent suspension request: the fact that the winner is not a Recupel member does not prove that its lump-sum global price leaves out environmental costs, and an award decision that discloses only total scores is adequately reasoned where all criteria are purely mathematical and the competitor’s sub-scores can be recalculated from the tender formulas.
What happened?
The Federal Public Service Justice awarded a supply contract for ‘the supply of refrigerators and freezers for the new Antwerp prison’ through a negotiated procedure without prior publication (Article 42(1)(1)(a) of the Act of 17 June 2016), advertised nationally under specification NA2026001. Lot 1 covered 610 tabletop fridges without freezer compartment (maximum 950 by 600 millimetres, 120 to 145 litres, at least energy label D, maximum 40 dB). It was a global-price contract: under point 11 of the specification the contractor was deemed to have included ‘all possible costs’ in its lump-sum price, expressly including ‘environmental levies and other possible taxes and charges’ and ‘any mandatory declaration/notification’. The award criteria were fully mathematical: price (75 points, lowest price divided by the price assessed), delivery time (10 points, shortest delivery time divided by the time offered) and energy label (15 points, using a fixed scale A = 10, B = 7.5, C = 5, D = 0, converted to 15). Twelve tenders were received for lot 1. All bidders were selected, but several tenders were declared substantially irregular because the bidders did not regularise them; eight remained. Only company A was asked to justify its price, which was more than 50% below the estimate (a misreading of the specification it later corrected). After the initial assessment, S. BV ranked first with 84.45 points and W. BV second with 79.38. The FPS negotiated on price and delivery time; W. BV improved its delivery time, S. BV both its price and delivery time. Final ranking after the BAFOs: S. BV 85.69 points, W. BV 80.69. On 5 July 2026 the Director of Procurement awarded lot 1 to S. BV for EUR 97,798.25 including VAT; W. BV had bid EUR 116,076.51. After notification (by e-mail on 17 July 2026, then by registered mail), W. BV asked how the FPS had verified that S. BV complied with the Belgian and European obligations on waste electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE). Recupel had told it on 23 July 2026 that S. BV was not a Recupel member. The FPS maintained its decision, and on 6 August 2026 W. BV sought suspension under the extreme urgency procedure. The first plea (flawed regularity check, breach of the global-price clause) failed. The Council first partly upheld the State’s objection of obscurity: W. BV merely referred in a footnote to Directive 2012/19/EU and the Flemish VLAREMA, without naming a single provision allegedly breached. The Council did examine the core of the plea — should the FPS have checked whether S. BV’s price covered environmental costs? — but found it not serious either. The specification did not require proof of Recupel membership or any other evidence of WEEE compliance with the tender. A confidential document also showed that S. BV had had an agreement with Afvalbeheerstructuur AEEA BV since 2021, so non-membership of Recupel did not by itself show non-compliance. S. BV had offered a lump-sum global price without reservation and was therefore deemed to have included all costs. Recupel’s e-mail moreover post-dated the award: before deciding, the FPS had no concrete indication requiring further investigation. The second plea (reasoning and transparency) also failed. The non-confidential version of the award decision set out the formulas, W. BV’s own sub-scores (63.19 for price, 10 for delivery time, 7.5 for energy label), all bidders’ total scores and the award price, but left S. BV’s sub-scores blank. The Council rejected the objection of lack of interest, but then itself showed that those sub-scores could be determined: as the cheapest bidder S. BV received 75 points for price; of its 85.69 points, 10.69 remained, and since the energy label could only yield 0, 7.50, 11.25 or 15 points, that remainder can only consist of 7.50 for energy label (label C) and 3.19 for delivery time. A narrative assessment was superfluous for purely mathematical criteria, and the FPS did not have to disclose which appliance the winner offered or how its price was built up. The request was dismissed. W. BV also asked that costs be borne by the State, since it learned only from the State’s note of observations that the contract had already been concluded and was being performed, whereas the notification referred to a 15-day suspension remedy. That too was rejected: any defect in the notification does not affect the legality of the decision, no (voluntary or mandatory) standstill period applied, and the notification expressly stated that the reference to remedies was ‘to be understood in no other way than as a mere communication’. W. BV bears the EUR 200 court fee, the EUR 26 contribution and EUR 770 in procedural costs.
Why does this matter?
The judgment touches on three questions that keep recurring in supply contracts. The first is how far the regularity check must go in a global-price contract. The Council’s answer is down to earth: a bidder offering a lump-sum price without reservation is deemed to have included all costs, and the contracting authority need not hunt for hidden cost items absent any concrete indication that something is wrong. Anyone accusing a competitor of an incomplete price must bring more than a suspicion that it is ‘in all likelihood’ non-compliant. The second is the evidential value of a negative attestation. That a competitor is not a Recupel member looked like a strong argument, but Recupel is not the only way to meet WEEE take-back obligations — the winner turned out to work with another waste-management scheme. The information also came only after the award: what the authority could not know when deciding does not make its decision careless. The third — how much must an award decision disclose about the winner? — gets a practical answer. With fully mathematical criteria it suffices that the sub-scores are determinable. The Council worked them out in the judgment itself, down to the winner’s energy label C. That is a clear signal: an unsuccessful bidder receiving a decision with blank fields must first do the arithmetic before alleging defective reasoning. Finally, the costs ruling confirms that a reference to remedies in the notification does not imply a tacit standstill period in a negotiated procedure without prior publication.
The lesson
For bidders: suspicions are not pleas. If you argue that the winner’s tender is irregular, name the specific rule allegedly breached, explain when it had to be met and provide prima facie evidence that the authority should have noticed before the award. A general footnote reference to a directive and the VLAREMA is not enough, nor is a Recupel e-mail dated after the award. If you receive an award decision with blank sub-scores for the winner, run the tender formulas first: if the scores can be derived, a reasoning plea is doomed. And do not assume that an authority using a negotiated procedure without prior publication will wait before concluding the contract just because the notification mentions time limits for remedies. For contracting authorities: a well-documented regularity and price check, a specification that makes the global price expressly all-inclusive and an award decision stating the formulas, each bidder’s own sub-scores, all total scores and the award price make an award very robust. If you want a particular environmental obligation (such as WEEE scheme membership) to be proven with the tender, say so expressly in the specification; otherwise you cannot hold bidders to it, nor need you check it without concrete cause. State clearly in the notification whether or not you will observe a standstill period — it avoids arguments about costs.
Ask yourself
If you accuse a competitor of an incomplete global price, can you point to the precise provision it breaches and show that the authority could have known before the award? Before alleging defective reasoning, have you used the tender formulas to check whether the winner’s sub-scores can be derived from the information disclosed? Do you know that not being a Recupel member does not mean a supplier fails to meet its WEEE obligations? As a contracting authority: does your specification expressly require proof, with the tender, of the environmental obligations you care about, or do you leave that to the global-price clause? Does your award notification state clearly whether you will wait before concluding the contract, and that the reference to remedies is merely informative?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →