Ziekenhuis Oost-Limburg let only the winner submit a BAFO: 893,056-euro lift renovation award definitively annulled
After the Council of State had suspended, in January 2026, the award of the lift renovation at Ziekenhuis Oost-Limburg to nv T. because only that bidder had been given an extra meeting and a BAFO, the hospital did not ask for the proceedings to be continued — whereupon the Council annulled the award decision of 8 December 2025 for both lots under the accelerated procedure and ordered the hospital to pay the costs.
What happened?
Ziekenhuis Oost-Limburg (ZOL) used a competitive procedure with negotiation to tender the renovation of a staff lift group (lot 1) and a logistics lift group involving asbestos works (lot 2) at its Sint-Jan campus in Genk, with the special condition that at least one lift in each group had to remain in service at all times. Specification 2025-282 weighted bids on price (40 points), work plan (30), execution period (15) and functional value (15). Three candidates were selected and two submitted a bid: NV K. and nv T. On the initial bids, NV K. was provisionally ranked first for lot 1 (70 against 68.4 points) and second for lot 2 (70 against 72.3). After a presentation session on 9 September 2025, both bidders were asked on 26 September 2025 to submit an improved bid: NV K. with a view to an ‘open source’ control system, nv T. with a view to adapted doors. NV K. replied that the specification did not require open source and that its products already respected its principles; nv T. submitted an improved bid on 1 October 2025. What the award report left out: on 5 November 2025 the hospital held an additional meeting with nv T. and invited only that bidder to submit a BAFO, which arrived on 13 November 2025 with prices changed once more. In the final ranking nv T. scored 76.6 and 80.4 points against 70 each time for NV K., and on 8 December 2025 the board of directors confirmed the award of both lots to nv T. for 271,050 euros and 518,680 euros excl. VAT, together 893,056.39 euros incl. VAT. By judgment no. 265.628 of 30 January 2026 the Council of State suspended that award under extreme urgency. The second plea was serious: the ‘review report’ gave an incomplete and incorrect account of the negotiations (it claimed the improved bids of 2 October were the final ones, whereas the BAFO of 13 November was evaluated), the hospital breached specification clause 1.10, which promises a BAFO to all ‘remaining bidders’ — everyone not placed in the ‘waiting room’ — and the principle of equal treatment was breached because NV K. received neither a second meeting nor a BAFO opportunity. The claim against the implicit decision not to award to NV K. was already held inadmissible at that stage. After the suspension judgment the hospital did not file a request for continuation of the proceedings. It thereby did not contest the assessment of the second plea, and the Council saw no reason not to confirm on the merits the illegality provisionally found. By this judgment of 2 September 2026 the president of the XIVth chamber therefore annuls the award decision of 8 December 2025 for both lots. Since NV K., for its part, did not request continuation for the rejected part, the presumption of discontinuance applies to the implicit refusal decision. The hospital bears the costs of the urgency proceedings: a 200-euro roll fee, a 26-euro contribution and a 770-euro procedural indemnity for NV K.
Why does this matter?
The judgment itself is short, but it closes a case that says a great deal about negotiated procedures. The substantive lesson comes from the suspension judgment: an authority has wide latitude in negotiations, but must give every bidder the same opportunities to improve its bid, abide by the rules it wrote into its own specification, and give an honest account of the negotiations in the award report. ZOL failed on all three: an extra meeting and a BAFO for one bidder, no decision to place the other in the ‘waiting room’, and a report that presented the negotiations differently from how they actually went. This annulment judgment also shows the procedural mechanism that kicks in after such a suspension: an authority that does not request continuation within thirty days of notification of the suspension judgment in effect accepts that the suspension is turned into an annulment, without any new debate on the merits. Conversely, a bidder that does not itself request continuation for what was rejected at the suspension stage loses that part through a presumption of discontinuance. The difference between a suspension and an annulment is considerable: an award worth almost 900,000 euros has now disappeared from the legal order.
The lesson
For contracting authorities: if you negotiate, document every step and offer every opportunity equally. If, after improved bids, you want to hold further talks with one bidder or ask only that bidder for a BAFO, first take a formal, reasoned decision to place the other bidders in the waiting room — especially if your specification, as here, promises a BAFO to all ‘remaining bidders’. Record in the award report what actually happened, with dates and bid versions, and file the complete administrative file. And be aware that not filing a request for continuation after a suspension in practice amounts to accepting annulment. For bidders: if the authority invites you to improve your bid, do not read that invitation too narrowly and use the opportunity to improve other points as well. If you find that a competitor got an extra round after the improved bids and you did not, you have a strong plea. Finally, do not forget to file a timely request for continuation for the parts rejected at the suspension stage if you want to maintain them.
Ask yourself
As an authority: after the improved bids, did you give all bidders still in the running the same opportunity for talks and for submitting a BAFO, or did you formally and with reasons decide to place some of them in the waiting room? Does your award report reflect the actual course of the negotiations, including every meeting, every bid version and the prices you ultimately relied on? Are you complying with the negotiation rules you yourself included in your specification? As a bidder: did you read an invitation to improve your bid broadly enough to improve every point that affects the score? Do you know that you must file a request for continuation within thirty days of notification of a (partly) rejected suspension claim, failing which discontinuance is presumed?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →