Ghent was entitled to examine twenty ‘valuable greenery’ items together: the lowest bidder for the Spellewerkstraat cluster stays excluded for abnormally low unit prices
The joint venture TM N.-A. submitted the lowest price, 3,756,336.33 euros, for the redevelopment of the Spellewerkstraat cluster in Ghent, but was excluded because its unit prices for protecting valuable greenery against groundwater lowering were 77 percent below average; ruling under extreme urgency, the Council of State accepts that the City could group those items, that the 1% threshold refers to the average of all bids, and that arguments first raised in the application are an ineffective post-factum justification.
What happened?
The City of Ghent, acting as contracting authority for a joint contract with the inter-municipal association Farys, launched an open procedure for the complete redevelopment — sewerage and road surface, from façade to façade — of the Spellewerkstraat, Satijnstraat and Kantstraat and the adjoining junctions (specifications TDW/2026/006 – ID5903). Price was the sole award criterion. Six bidders submitted a tender by 26 May 2026. After checking, TM N.-A., formed by NV N. and NV A., was cheapest at 3,756,336.33 euros, followed by Company P. (3,767,728.56 euros), Company V. (3,865,511.48 euros) and nv O. (3,891,298.94 euros). No total price was more than 15 percent below average, but the City also examined unit prices. Under its method, an item was ‘significant’ if its average price exceeded 1 percent of the average total price; a unit price was apparently abnormally low at 30 percent below, and apparently abnormally high at 50 percent above, the average. The City also grouped items 73 to 92 — measures to limit the effect of dewatering on old, valuable greenery, per green zone and per works phase — because together they accounted for 2.82 percent of the average total price and were an essential part of the specifications. For that group, TM N.-A.’s price was 77 percent below average. Asked on 5 June 2026 to justify its prices, the joint venture replied by email on 17 June. The verification report accepted part of the explanation, but found that it provided no soil-moisture sensors, no additional piezometers at the green zones, too little PE40 distribution pipe for the more distant zones G4 and G7/G7a, a weekly inspection of barely fifteen minutes and 1 euro of electricity per week for the pump. P. and V. were also excluded for abnormal unit prices. nv O.’s tender, which for the same group of items was 33 percent above the estimate, was accepted ‘partly in view of the importance of preserving the valuable greenery’. On 20 August 2026 the college awarded the contract to O. On 4 September TM N.-A. sought suspension under extreme urgency. It argued that the City had breached its own 1% rule by combining twenty items (only 0.64 percent of its own tender), that O.’s tender had not been tested in the same way, that compliance with the specifications must not be confused with price abnormality, and it rebutted the objections point by point: the sensors were ‘obviously’ included in the price, groundwater levels were monitored through its own dewatering filters, the PE40 pipe came from site stock and a mobile solar-panel unit brought the electricity cost to zero. The Council did not agree. Neither the Act nor the Royal Decree imposes a method for selecting items or determining whether they are negligible; this must be assessed in light of the specific contract, and the grouping was functionally and substantively justified. The 1% threshold is applied to the average total price of all bids — that way outliers are averaged out and the same yardstick applies to everyone. O.’s tender had in fact been examined, with the estimate as a reasonable benchmark because the average had been distorted by two abnormally low bids. Price examination is part of the regularity assessment and may reveal precisely that required services are not priced in, even with an ‘all-in’ price. The new explanations about sensors, filters, PE40 and solar panels were not in the price justification and counted as post-factum justification. A second round of questions was not required because the justification contained enough information to decide. The plea is not serious; the application is dismissed. The applicants each bear half of the costs: 400 euros roll fee, 26 euros contribution and 770 euros procedural indemnity for the City; O. bears its 150-euro intervention fee.
Why does this matter?
The judgment addresses three questions that come up in every price inquiry. First: may an authority bundle individual items to determine what is ‘not negligible’? Yes, as long as there is a functional and substantive link and it is explained in the verification report. Twenty items that each stay below the radar can together trigger the inquiry. Second: against what base is a threshold measured? The Council accepts prima facie that a 1% threshold is calculated on the average of all bids, not on the bidder’s own tender — otherwise precisely the bidder who prices too low could push its item below the threshold. Third, and most painful for bidders: what is not in the price justification does not count. TM N.-A. had plausible-sounding answers in its application — solar panels, site stock, its own dewatering filters — but they came too late. The judgment also confirms that the estimate is a valid benchmark when the average has been skewed by abnormally low bids, and that there is no right to a second round of questions when the first justification sufficed to decide. The outcome: the lowest bidder loses a contract of almost 3.8 million euros over items that made up less than 1 percent of its own price.
The lesson
For bidders: treat a request for price justification as the moment your tender is won or lost, even when it concerns small items. Go through every requirement in the specifications that touches the items queried (here: sensors, piezometers, pipe lengths per zone, inspection hours, energy) and show for each where it sits in your price; ‘that goes without saying’ or ‘that is in the all-in price’ is not enough. If you depart from the method prescribed by the specifications, say so in the justification itself and substantiate why your alternative is equivalent. Do not count on being able to supplement it before the Council of State, nor on a second round of questions. For contracting authorities: set out your method in the verification report — the thresholds, the calculation base and why you group items — and apply it to all bidders. If the average is distorted, state explicitly why you use the estimate as the benchmark for the chosen bidder. That transparency made the difference here.
Ask yourself
As a bidder: do you know which items in your tender, added up per function or works phase, could together exceed a significance threshold, even though each item on its own is small? Does your price justification show concretely, for each requirement in the specifications, where it sits in the price, or do you rely on ‘that is obvious’? Have you expressly included any alternative working method (your own filters, material from site stock, your own energy supply) in your justification, so you do not have to raise it later ‘post factum’? As a contracting authority: does your verification report state which thresholds you use, against which base you calculate them and why you group items? Where the average is distorted by abnormally low bids, have you explained which alternative yardstick (e.g. the estimate) you use to test the prices of the remaining bidders?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →