Suspension Dutch-speaking chamber

An ‘extract’ without a parent decision: Farys excludes a road-marking tender for abnormal prices, but the reasons appear nowhere in the award decision itself

Ruling nr. 267993 · 9 October 2026 · XIVe kamer

Farys excluded R. BV’s tender for a road-marking framework agreement on grounds of abnormal prices and sent it an ‘extract of the reasons’, but the board’s actual decision contained only one general sentence, did not refer to the award report and relied on a presentation that was not in the file — so it was not established that the reasons communicated were the real ones, and the Council of State suspended the award under extreme urgency.

What happened?

The Opdrachthoudende Vereniging Farys launched an open procedure for a works contract: a ‘Framework agreement for the (re)application and maintenance of (road) markings’, divided into two regional lots — lot 1 for East and West Flanders, lot 2 for Antwerp, Flemish Brabant and Limburg. Six tenderers submitted bids. R. BV and the eventually chosen tenderer both bid for both lots. Farys asked R., among others, for a price justification, which R. submitted on 26 June 2026. On 27 August 2026 Farys’s board awarded the contract to the chosen tenderer. In that decision R.’s price justification was not accepted and its tender was declared irregular. A day later, on 28 August 2026, R. received a letter stating that its tender had been excluded, enclosing ‘the extract of the reasons concerning the rejection of [its] tender’. It did not receive the full award decision. On 11 September 2026 R. applied for suspension under extreme urgency of that decision, which its application described as a decision ‘of unknown date’ of which only an extract of the ‘alleged content’ had been communicated. In the first limb of its single plea it argued that an extract must give the excluded tenderer all relevant reasons, so that it can judge whether an appeal makes sense. Farys replied that the notification letter corresponded ‘one to one’ with the relevant passages of the award report, that R. had no right to the full report and that the purpose of the duty to state reasons had in any event been achieved, since R. had been able to formulate extensive substantive criticism of the price assessment. Chamber president Geert Debersaques set the notification letter against the document Farys had filed in the administrative file as the actual award decision of 27 August 2026. On R.’s tender it contained a single sentence: that, ‘after price examination and review of the submitted price justification’, it was irregular ‘since the prices show an apparently abnormal character that has not been sufficiently rebutted’. Which prices, and why the justification failed to convince, could not be inferred from it. The reasons in the letter therefore found no support in the decision, and the letter was not an (adequate) ‘extract’ of it. Reasoning by reference to the award report could not save the day either: the decision did not mention that report anywhere, referring only to an ‘explanation by means of a presentation projected at the meeting’ — and that presentation was not in the administrative file either. That R., by its own account, had obtained the award report ‘through a fair wind’ and could criticise it on substance was irrelevant according to the Council: nothing showed that the board had taken note of that report or adopted its reasons as its own. The first limb of the plea was serious, in line with the opinion of first auditor Thomas Maes, and on 9 October 2026 the Council ordered the suspension of the award decision. The second limb, containing the substantive criticism of the price examination, was not examined.

Why does this matter?

Article 8 of the Act of 17 June 2013 allows a contracting authority not to send an excluded tenderer the whole award decision, but only an extract containing the reasons for its exclusion. This judgment makes clear what that word means: an extract is a piece taken from the decision. The reasons you communicate must therefore be in the decision itself, or in a document to which that decision clearly refers. In practice this is exactly where things often go wrong. Staff or a consultant write a detailed award report, the governing body takes a short decision, and the notification letter quotes freely from the report. As long as the decision does not expressly adopt or refer to the report, there is no guarantee that the reasons communicated are the reasons of the competent body. For an exclusion on grounds of abnormal prices this weighs even more heavily, because article 5, 8°, of the same Act specifically requires legal and factual reasons for that exclusion. Equally important is what the Council says about the purpose of the duty to state reasons. The defence that the tenderer ‘knew everything anyway’ and could criticise at length achieves nothing if it is not established that the reasons criticised actually underlie the decision. A leaked award report does not cure a defective decision.

The lesson

For contracting authorities: make sure the competent body’s decision contains the reasons itself, or refers expressly to the award report and states that it endorses it. File that report, and any presentation or note on which the decision relies, in the administrative file. A formula such as ‘the prices show an apparently abnormal character that has not been sufficiently rebutted’ is a conclusion, not a statement of reasons. For every notification letter, check that what you send as an ‘extract’ can literally be found in the decision or the endorsed report. For bidders: if you only receive an extract, ask for the decision itself and compare. If the reasoning in the letter does not match what the governing body decided, you have a plea that is independent of the substantive debate about your prices. Here that formal defect was enough for a suspension, without the Council even having to look at the price justification.

Ask yourself

As an authority: are the reasons for every exclusion contained in the competent body’s decision itself, or does that decision refer expressly to an award report it endorses? Is every document the decision refers to — report, note, presentation — in the administrative file? Can the text of your notification letter be found literally in that decision or report? As a bidder: have you seen the actual award decision, or only a letter with an ‘extract’? And do you know that the reasons for an exclusion on grounds of abnormal prices must be concrete, not merely a conclusion?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →