Rejection Dutch-speaking chamber

Lowest bidder in Bertem, yet no contract: Interleuven could halt the sewerage works in the Opstreek housing estate and retender them so as not to build roads to land it did not yet own

Ruling nr. 207385 · 16 September 2010 · XIIe kamer

At EUR 969,194.51, Aannemingen Willems was the cheapest of ten bidders for the road and sewerage works in the Opstreek estate in Bertem, but Interleuven did not award the contract, informed it only six months later and retendered a smaller contract, which Marcel Nijs offered more cheaply — and the Council of State held that dropping the second phase, so as not to build infrastructure next to land not yet acquired, was a sound reason for retendering.

What happened?

The intermunicipal company Interleuven put out a public tender for road and sewerage works in the ‘Opstreek’ housing estate in Bertem, under specifications no. A-5031. The performance period was 220 working days in two phases: earthworks, sewerage and sub-bases in 130 working days, then roads and planting in 90 working days. It was a mixed contract with both lump-sum items and items at estimated quantities. On 9 July 2009 ten tenders were opened. NV Aannemingen Willems offered the lowest price, EUR 969,194.51; NV Marcel Nijs was second with EUR 1,008,983.37. On 27 August 2009 Interleuven discussed the file with the engineering firm GVE. Comments were made on items in the bill of quantities, the sewerage, the landscaping and the ‘Longitudinal profiles’ and ‘Roadworks’ drawings, along with the suggestion to retender ‘given the various errors in the specifications, bill of quantities and drawings’, with phasing so that the roads along the land not yet acquired would follow later. On 9 September 2009 the management committee decided that the infrastructure was best built in phases, that a solution was needed for access to the land not yet acquired in the residential expansion area, and that ‘no unnecessary infrastructure’ should be built. The specifications were amended to no. W-5031. Aannemingen Willems learned only on 26 March 2010 that the works would be retendered ‘following changes’. The new notice appeared on 29 March 2010 in the Belgian Tender Bulletin; the required registration fell from category C class 5 to class 4. On 5 May 2010 twelve tenders were opened. Now Marcel Nijs was the cheapest at EUR 700,450.67 incl. VAT; Aannemingen Willems came second at EUR 744,047.00 incl. VAT. On 26 May 2010 Aannemingen Willems sought suspension of the decision not to award and to retender. It argued that, as the lowest regular bidder, it had been left in the dark for more than six months; that the reasoning was inadequate since the original specifications already provided for phasing; that the differences between the two sets of specifications — including PVC instead of stoneware connection pipes, additional L-shaped retaining elements and changed quantities — were so limited that they could have been handled through variation orders under Article 42 of the General Contract Conditions during performance; and that equality had been breached because its price was already known from the first opening. The Council of State dismissed the application. A late notification does not in principle render a decision unlawful. The formal reasoning sufficed: Aannemingen Willems had itself attached the management committee’s report to its application and contested the reasons at length. On the merits, Interleuven was entitled under Article 18 of the Law of 24 December 1993 to refrain from awarding and to start again, provided it did not act arbitrarily. The original phasing was merely a division of the performance period within a single awarded contract; the new approach removed the second phase from the contract entirely, to be tendered separately later, reducing the period to 110 working days. Not wanting to build alongside land not yet acquired, whose development was uncertain, was in itself a sufficient reason. The items in the two bills of quantities could not simply be compared either, since the numbering had shifted. Article 17 of the Law governs additional works after award, not omissions, and the right of variation under Article 42 of the General Contract Conditions applies to changes whose need emerges only after award; handling changes already known before award through a variation order would breach equal treatment of bidders. Nor were the changes minimal, given their impact on the estimate, the prices and the registration class. Article 15 could not have been breached either: no award was made, and Interleuven had not even examined the tenders for regularity. Finally, knowledge of prices is inherent in restarting after a public tender, and Aannemingen Willems knew its competitors’ prices just as well. Marcel Nijs, which had initially sought to intervene, withdrew and bears the EUR 125 costs of its intervention.

Why does this matter?

The judgment shows the limits of the lowest bidder’s position. The cheapest bidder in a public tender is entitled to the contract if it is awarded, but not to an award as such: the contracting authority may refrain and start again, provided its reason is sound and not arbitrary. A revision of the subject matter of the contract — here dropping a phase because the land had not yet been acquired — carries great weight. The judgment also makes a point of principle that still holds: changes the authority already knows it wants before award do not belong in variation orders during performance. That would favour a bidder who priced a different subject matter and distort competition. Retendering is then the cleanest route. Finally, the Council confirms that disclosure of prices at the first opening does not breach equality, since everyone has the same information and the contract has changed.

The lesson

For bidders: the lowest price does not entitle you to an award. If the authority stops and retenders, you must show that its reason is unsound — an argument that the changes ‘could also have been made during performance’ rarely succeeds if the authority knew of them before award. Prepare for the second round: your competitors know your previous price, but you know theirs just as well, and with a changed subject matter that old price says little. A late notification is frustrating but does not make the decision unlawful; do react quickly once you learn of it. For contracting authorities: if you identify errors or a changed need after opening, retendering is better than pushing changes into performance, but give concrete reasons — here, no infrastructure alongside land not yet acquired — and inform bidders straight away rather than waiting six months. Also avoid inconsistent references in your documents (here A-5021 versus A-5031).

Ask yourself

Do you know that, as the lowest bidder in a public tender, you have no right to an award, only to the award going to the lowest regular tender if an award is made? Can you show that the reason for retendering is arbitrary or unreasonable, and not merely that the changes could have been handled differently? In a retender, did you recalculate your price on the changed subject matter rather than relying on the prices from the first opening? As a contracting authority: did you know of the desired changes before award? Then equal treatment calls for retendering, not a variation order. As a contracting authority: do you inform bidders promptly of a decision not to award, together with the reasons?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →