Rejection Dutch-speaking chamber

‘(184 h)’ next to a lump-sum item: law firm Cottyn made its price for the Harelbeke weir ambiguous and was rightly excluded

Ruling nr. 207762 · 30 September 2010 · XIIe kamer

Law firm Cottyn was by far the cheapest bidder, at 140,500 euros, for the legal and technical support of the Design & Build contract for the weir on the Leie in Harelbeke, but by adding ‘(184 h)’ and an hourly rate of 125 euros by hand to the lump-sum item ‘drafting the specifications’, it made it unclear whether it was still offering a fixed price, so Waterwegen en Zeekanaal could exclude the tender as substantially irregular and the Council of State refused suspension.

What happened?

In May 2010 Waterwegen en Zeekanaal NV (Upper Scheldt division) launched an open call for tenders for legal and technical assistance with the Design & Build contract for the weir on the Leie in Harelbeke. The contract was published on 3 May 2010 in the Belgian Tenders Bulletin and on 5 May 2010 in the Official Journal of the EU, and was estimated at 330,000 euros excluding VAT. Specifications 16EGGE/10/08 described a mixed contract with two sub-contracts: legal support during the contracting phase and drafting of the specifications, and legal support during the execution phase. In the bill of quantities, item 1.1.1 ‘drafting the specifications’ was a lump-sum item (GP) with quantity 1. Items 1.1.2 and 1.2.1 were estimated quantities of 200 and 500 hours, and provisional sums were provided for unforeseen services. The specifications expressly stated that the quantities in the bill could not be corrected. When tenders were opened on 22 June 2010, there were three timely tenders: Arcadis Belgium NV (594,440 euros), Cottyn, Roseleth, Van de Steen & Co BVBA (140,500 euros) and Grontmij Vlaanderen NV (326,050 euros), all excluding VAT. Two other tenders arrived late. The evaluation report declared the tender of law firm Cottyn substantially irregular. The tender form stated no total amount, and the price could not be unambiguously derived from the bill of quantities either. Next to lump-sum item 1.1.1, Cottyn had added ‘(184 h)’ by hand, entered a unit price of ‘125 €/hour’ and a total of 23,000 euros, and written ‘No VAT!’ at the VAT line, whereas legal and technical advice was, according to the authority, subject to 21 % VAT. The contract went to Grontmij Vlaanderen for 394,520.50 euros including VAT. Cottyn was informed by registered letter of 26 August 2010 (mistakenly dated 20 April 2010) and on 10 September 2010 applied for suspension under extreme urgency. Grontmij intervened in the proceedings. Because the contract had been published after 24 February 2010, the new remedies regime of the Act of 23 December 2009 applied: serious harm difficult to repair was no longer required, only a serious plea. Cottyn argued that, as a law firm, it was exempt from VAT (article 44, § 1, 1°, VAT Code), that the total price did appear in figures in the tender, and that ‘(184 h)’ was not a change but a clarification to allow comparison with the other tenders, since the GP mention and quantity 1 had not been crossed out. Presiding judge Dierk Verbiest did not accept that reading. A lump-sum item calls for a fixed price, whatever the number of hours. By adding 184 hours and an hourly rate, Cottyn at least gave the impression that its price was limited to 184 hours, and created uncertainty as to whether work beyond those 184 hours was included. As a result, the total price was no longer certain either. Such ambiguity affects price formation and the risk the bidder is willing to bear, and therefore the comparability of tenders. The authority could therefore declare the tender substantially irregular under article 110, § 2, of the Royal Decree of 8 January 1996. Since that ground sufficed on its own, Cottyn no longer had an interest in its criticism of the VAT ground. The Council also noted that the missing documents proving authority to sign were not the ground for exclusion. The application was dismissed; Grontmij bore the costs of its intervention (125 euros).

Why does this matter?

This 2010 judgment remains relevant because it shows a mistake that still costs bids today: the bidder who ‘clarifies’ a bill of quantities and thereby changes the nature of an item. A lump-sum item is a promise to deliver a service for a fixed price, whatever it takes. Whoever adds a number of hours and an hourly rate unintentionally shifts the risk of extra work back to the authority, or at least leaves doubt about it. For the Council this is not a formality but a question of price, an essential element of the tender. Form does not matter either: the fact that ‘GP’ and ‘1’ were not crossed out changed nothing, as the handwritten addition was enough to make the commitment ambiguous. The judgment is also instructive for law firms and other service providers that were then still VAT-exempt or are subject to a special tax regime: such a tax position does not belong in the bill of quantities without more, and certainly not alongside another ambiguity. Because the lump-sum ground alone supported the exclusion, the Council did not rule on the VAT question. Finally, the case illustrates the then-new regime of the Act of 23 December 2009: since 25 February 2010 an unsuccessful bidder no longer had to show serious harm difficult to repair, but that does not help if the pleas are not serious.

The lesson

Bidders: complete the bill of quantities as drafted. Where it says GP and quantity 1, give one fixed price without hours, hourly rates or conditions. If you want to show your calculation, do so in a separate price breakdown table (which the specifications even required here) and not in the bill itself. Always enter the total amount on the tender form. If you have a tax particularity such as a VAT exemption, ask the authority a question during the procedure rather than writing ‘no VAT’ in the bill. A spectacularly low price (here 140,500 euros against an estimate of 330,000 euros) also draws extra attention to every ambiguity. Contracting authorities: state expressly in the specifications that the bill may not be altered, as happened here, and give reasons for an exclusion ground by ground, so that each ground can support the decision on its own. Date your letters correctly: a notification mistakenly dated before the contract was even published invites confusion about what is being challenged.

Ask yourself

Have you entered a single fixed price for every lump-sum item (GP), without adding hours, hourly rates or reservations? Does the total amount of your tender appear unambiguously on the tender form and in the signed bill of quantities? Do the specifications allow quantities in the bill to be changed? If not, have you left them untouched, even ‘for clarification’? Have you agreed any tax particularity (such as VAT) with the authority in good time, instead of imposing it in the bill of quantities? As a contracting authority: does each exclusion ground support the decision on its own, and is that clear from the award report? As a contracting authority: are the dates and references in your notifications to bidders correct?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →