Five years on, Limburg re-awards the same communications contract to the same agency, retroactively — and the Council of State, against the auditor’s advice, finds that permissible
After the Council of State had annulled the award of a regional-marketing contract to Groep C & Slangen because the province of Limburg had translated price differences of over 100,000 euros into just three points, the provincial executive re-scored price with a proportional formula, again came out with the same agency and awarded the long-performed contract retroactively to 2002; the Council — departing from the auditor’s report — rejects Allcomm’s plea that this breached the ban on retroactivity and the res judicata of the annulment, and reopens the proceedings on the remaining pleas.
What happened?
In April 2002 the province of Limburg issued a general call for tenders for a strategic regional-marketing concept, translated into an image, a slogan and a communications strategy. The specifications set four equal award criteria: price, methodology, expertise of the staff involved and own vision of the assignment, each worth 25 points. Four agencies bid on 28 May 2002: TWBA (65,900 euros excl. VAT), Allcomm (119,067.04 euros), Impuls (154,446 euros) and Groep C & Slangen (171,415 euros). On price they received 25, 24, 23 and 22 points respectively — one point apart each time, while scores on the other criteria ranged from 10 to 25. On 27 June 2002 the provincial executive awarded the contract to the most expensive bidder, Groep C & Slangen. Allcomm lodged an annulment action on 28 October 2002 and, on 10 December 2003, sued the province and the Flemish Region for damages before the Brussels court of first instance. Meanwhile the contract with C & Slangen was performed. By judgment no. 168.990 of 15 March 2007 the Council of State annulled the award: by translating a 105,515-euro price gap between the cheapest and most expensive bids into a mere three points, the province had subordinated the price criterion to the other three, contrary to its own specifications and to equality between bidders. On 10 May 2007 the executive took a new decision. It again endorsed the original assessment of methodology, expertise and vision, but now scored price using the formula ‘lowest price / price of bid assessed × 25’. That gave TWBA 25 points, Allcomm 14, Impuls 11 and C & Slangen 10. Overall, however, C & Slangen stayed ahead with 85 points against Allcomm (80), Impuls (64) and TWBA (55), because it kept the maximum score on the three qualitative criteria. The executive therefore awarded the contract ‘again and retroactively’ from 27 June 2002 to C & Slangen, for 201,612 euros incl. VAT, expressly because the contract already concluded had lost its legal basis. Allcomm, by then Spitz, challenged that decision too. In its first plea it argued that an award meant to cover an already performed contract after the event breaches the ban on retroactivity, that no pressing public-interest reason justified it, and that the res judicata of judgment no. 168.990 was breached because only the price score had been recalculated with a formula not in the specifications, while the rest of the assessment was left untouched. It added that the decision mainly served to shield the province in the pending damages proceedings. The auditor had found the plea well founded, but the Council disagreed. An authority whose decision has been annulled may decide again and even take the same decision; that the contract had long been concluded and performed is no more of an obstacle than it was before the annulment. Res judicata is only breached if the new decision suffers from the same illegality, which was not the case: the province had now scored price proportionally. Allcomm could derive from the annulment no right to be awarded the contract itself, nor to prevent the province from lawfully retaking its act. That the return to legality may indirectly affect the civil damages claim does not alter this. The Council held the first plea unfounded and, since the auditor’s report had only discussed that plea, reopened the proceedings and ordered a further investigation of the remaining pleas.
Why does this matter?
This interim judgment answers a question that arises more often than one might think: what may an authority do when the Council of State annuls an award but the contract has long been performed? The answer is broader than many bidders would expect. The authority may retake the decision, correct the unlawful element and — if the new assessment so yields — end up with the same winner, even retroactively to the original award date. Res judicata only obliges it not to repeat the illegality found; it does not oblige it to redo the whole assessment or to designate the applicant as winner. Strikingly, the Council here goes against the auditor’s advice and expressly calls the possible impact on the damages proceedings irrelevant. For an unsuccessful bidder, that is a sobering finding: a successful annulment action is no guarantee of the contract, and a remedial decision can alter the basis of a later damages claim. At the same time, the judgment shows how much a scoring method can matter: once price was scored proportionally, C & Slangen fell from 22 to 10 points, yet its maximum scores on the three qualitative criteria were enough to win anyway. Because the remaining pleas still had to be examined, this is not the last word on the legality of the remedial decision.
The lesson
Unsuccessful bidders: having an award annulled wins you a chance, not a contract. Expect that the authority may retake the decision, correct only the impugned element and again arrive at the same winner — even retroactively for an already performed contract. If you want to challenge that remedial decision, attack what is new about it: how the authority corrected the unlawful element, and whether the other assessments hold up. The argument ‘this is retroactive’ or ‘this only serves to escape the damages claim’ is not enough. Keep an eye, too, on the interaction with your damages proceedings. Contracting authorities: after an annulment you can provide redress by taking a new decision that removes the illegality found, and you may keep the original date. But the lesson starts earlier: score price proportionally to the weightings in your specifications from the outset. A price scale of 22 to 25 alongside quality scores of 10 to 25 turns an equally weighted price criterion into a formality, and here it cost the province years of litigation.
Ask yourself
After winning an annulment action, do you automatically expect the contract, or do you allow for a remedial decision that again ends with the same winner? Do you aim your criticism of a remedial decision at the way the illegality found was corrected, and not only at its retroactive effect? Have you mapped how a remedial decision might affect your pending damages claim? As an authority: does your price scoring translate price differences proportionally, with the same spread as the other criteria? As an authority: after an annulment, do you correct precisely the illegality the Council found, and explain this in the new decision?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →