Suspension French-speaking chamber

The chair opened the bids half an hour early, so the Châtelet social welfare centre wanted to start over: the Council of State suspends the relaunched tender for the heating of the Sart-Allet care home — fear of appeals is no ground

Ruling nr. 209059 · 22 November 2010 · VIe kamer

On 11 October 2010 the Châtelet public social welfare centre (CPAS) decided not to follow up the tender for the heating and sanitary installations of the Le Sart-Allet care home, because the information on the time for submitting and opening bids ‘could cause confusion’, but the Council of State suspended that decision at the request of Delta Thermic, the lowest bidder at 718,238.40 euros: the confusion had been caused by the chair, who opened the session at 10:00 instead of 10:30, the bids had nevertheless been opened and recorded in the minutes, and the fear of possible appeals did not justify restarting the procedure.

What happened?

The Châtelet CPAS organised a tender for the special techniques of the extension of its Le Sart-Allet care home; lot 1 covered heating and sanitary installations. The estimated value was below the EU threshold. The contract notice gave 30 September 2010 at 10:00 as the deadline for receipt of bids. The specifications said something else: every bid had to reach the chair of the opening session ‘before he declares the session open’, and the opening would take place on 30 September 2010 at 10:30, at the CPAS address in rue du Beau Moulin. In reality, the chair declared the session open at 10:00. The minutes recorded three bids, with the bidders’ names and prices. Delta Thermic was the cheapest at 718,238.40 euros; by its own account, it submitted its bid at 10:05. By a letter of 12 October 2010, received by Delta Thermic on 13 October, the CPAS announced that it would restart the procedure. Delta Thermic only received the decision itself, taken on 11 October 2010, on 27 October. The CPAS would not follow up the tender of 30 September, would inform the bidders, relaunched the contract with an opening on 22 November 2010 at 10:00, and would send the decision within fifteen days to the municipal executive and the provincial governor. The reasoning: ‘it is clear that the information on the time of receipt of bids and the time of the opening session could cause confusion’. A new notice appeared in the Bulletin of Tenders on 18 October 2010. On 12 November 2010 Delta Thermic sought suspension under extreme urgency. It argued that the decision to restart was not based on a legally admissible ground (article 18 of the Act of 24 December 1993) and breached equality between bidders. Had the CPAS truly considered its bid late, it should not have opened it (article 106, 3° of the Royal Decree of 8 January 1996) or recorded it in the minutes; having done so, it had to examine the bids and award the contract to the lowest regular bid. The CPAS replied that the admissibility of a bid that arrives late through the authority’s own error is controversial. An award excluding the two late bids could be challenged by both latecomers, an award including them by the bidder who had submitted before 10:00; faced with that risk, restarting was a lawful ground. Moreover, Delta Thermic could not claim to have submitted the lowest regular bid, since the bids had not yet been checked arithmetically. Presiding judge Paul Lewalle of the VIth chamber heard the case on 19 November 2010. The contract was below the EU threshold, so only title 3 of book IIbis of the Act of 24 December 1993 applied and no standstill period applied. The application had been lodged within the fifteen days of article 65/23(3), counted from receipt of the decision on 27 October, and extreme urgency was established prima facie. On the merits, the Council found the entries in the minutes clear. The assertion that the information on the times could cause confusion did not adequately justify the decision: if there was confusion, it was the work of the chair of the opening session, who had opened it at 10:00. The bids received had moreover not been rejected as late, but opened. The fear of possible appeals, relied on by the CPAS in its observations, did not prima facie justify abandoning the tender and restarting the procedure. The plea was serious. The CPAS did not show that the drawbacks of a suspension outweighed its benefits. The Council suspended the decision of 11 October 2010 — on the very day of the planned new opening — ordered immediate enforcement and notification by fax, but imposed no penalty payment, as nothing suggested the CPAS would disregard the judgment. Costs were reserved.

Why does this matter?

A contracting authority may decide not to award or to restart a procedure, but not without a legally admissible ground, and that ground must appear from the decision itself. This judgment shows where the line lies when the authority itself made the mistake. The chair opened the session half an hour earlier than the specifications announced, and the bids that arrived afterwards were still opened and recorded. The CPAS saw a legal minefield: exclude the late bids and the latecomers protest; accept them and the bidder who was on time protests. Starting over seemed the safest route. The Council of State did not accept that reasoning: fear of appeals is not in itself a ground for dropping a tender, and a general reference to ‘confusion’ does not suffice when the minutes are clear and the confusion arose from the authority’s own conduct. The practical importance of that line is plain: after the opening, all bidders know each other’s prices, and whoever must bid again in a new round does so with cards on the table. The judgment also has a sequel. A week after the suspension, on 29 November 2010, the CPAS withdrew its decision; Delta Thermic’s later action for annulment thereby became devoid of purpose (judgment no. 217.741). In practice, an authority wishing to correct its own procedural error must examine concretely, and state in its reasoning, whether that error really jeopardised the comparison of bids and equal treatment.

The lesson

For contracting authorities: make sure the notice and the specifications state the same time for submission and opening, and do not open the session earlier than announced. If it does go wrong, examine concretely which bids arrived when, whether anyone could benefit from the early opening and whether the comparison of bids was compromised, and set out that examination in the decision. A reference to ‘possible confusion’ or to the risk of appeals is not enough to drop a tender, certainly not after prices have been made public. For tenderers: note the exact time you submit your bid and ask for a copy of the opening minutes. If you are the lowest bidder and the authority wants to start over, check whether the reasoning examines the real consequences of the error. Count your fifteen days from the day you received the decision itself, but do not wait: here the new opening was already scheduled, and Delta Thermic obtained its suspension on that very day.

Ask yourself

Do your notice and your specifications state the same time for submission and for the opening of bids? Does the opening session start at the time stated in the procurement documents? If you want to restart a procedure because of your own mistake, have you examined concretely, and stated, whether that mistake really affected the comparison of bids or equal treatment? Does your decision not to award rest on more than the fear that someone will appeal? As a tenderer, have you kept the time you submitted your bid and the opening minutes?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →