Lowest bidder for a Schaerbeek care home is excluded over one blank page in the safety plan — and the Council of State sides with the CPAS
Sogepar Construct had the lowest price, 532,902.07 euros, for the plastering and ceiling works at the ‘La Cerisaie’ care home, but the CPAS of Schaerbeek rejected its bid because page 16 of the health and safety plan — the cost estimate for safety that had to be signed on pain of nullity — was blank; the Council of State saw this, prima facie, as a substantial irregularity and dismissed the extreme-urgency application.
What happened?
In July 2010 the CPAS (public social welfare centre) of Schaerbeek put out to public tender, with EU publication, the reconstruction of the ‘La Cerisaie’ residential care home on Chaussée de Haecht. Lot 02 covered partitions, plastering and suspended ceilings. Eight bids were opened on 30 August 2010. Sogepar Construct SPRL was cheapest at 532,902.07 euros excl. VAT, ahead of Poels Romain NV at 555,649.78 euros. Two bidders failed the qualitative selection, Ch. Jamar’s bid was rejected for an unsigned summary bill of quantities, and Sogepar Construct’s because it had ‘failed to submit its duly completed Safety price schedule’. Poels Romain’s bid was arithmetically corrected: it had given no price for item 02.30.0920, and on the basis of the regulations a unit price of 217.45 euros was calculated, adding 6,740.95 euros. On 23 September 2010 the social welfare council awarded the lot to Poels Romain for 562,390.73 euros excl. VAT — 29,488.66 euros more than Sogepar Construct’s price. The decision was only communicated by letter of 17 November 2010, received on 24 November 2010. That same day Sogepar Construct’s lawyer asked for the decision to be withdrawn; the CPAS merely acknowledged receipt. On 2 December 2010 a single application for suspension under the extreme-urgency procedure and annulment followed. The first plea argued that the bid was complete: safety page 14 of the plan had been filled in and even initialled, the safety cost was spread over all items, and not repeating that information on page 16 was at most a formal defect. The Council disagreed. Page 14 listed the safety items with their amounts and required no signature. Page 16 — ‘Estimate of the cost of safety’, ‘to be completed and signed by the bidder’ — contained different undertakings: acknowledgement of and compliance with the plan, a description of the firm’s own risks and any additional measures, and confirmation that the safety cost was not an extra item but spread over the items of the bill of quantities. The form expressly stated that the bid could be declared void if it was missing or unsigned. In Sogepar Construct’s bid that page was entirely blank, with no date or signature. The CPAS therefore could not determine whether the bidder’s means of execution carried particular risks, or whether additional measures had been planned and at what cost. The second plea — unequal treatment, because Poels Romain did get a correction — also failed: in a public tender the contracting authority may itself arithmetically remedy an omitted unit price without contacting the bidder, whereas a missing safety declaration could only be supplied by the bidder. Apart from a 0.10-euro rounding correction for Callewaert, no other correction appeared, prima facie, to have been made. The application was timely and extreme urgency was accepted, but without a serious plea it was dismissed; costs were reserved.
Why does this matter?
The judgment shows how hard a health and safety plan in the specifications can bite. What the bidder saw as needless repetition — page 14 had already been filled in — the Council regarded as a separate declaration with its own content: undertakings, the firm’s own risks, any additional measures and confirmation that the safety cost is included in the items. Because the form itself announced nullity and its wording was ‘unequivocal’, the authority could declare the bid irregular, even though it was almost 30,000 euros cheaper. Equally instructive is the distinction the Council draws between two kinds of defect. An omitted unit price is a remediable defect in a public tender: the regulations themselves provide a calculation method, and the authority can fill in a price without consulting the bidder. A missing declaration or undertaking can only be supplied by the bidder, which in a public tender — where contact during evaluation is in principle prohibited — would amount to correcting the bid after opening. Anyone invoking equal treatment must therefore show that the defects really are comparable.
The lesson
For bidders: treat every form the specifications describe as ‘to be completed and signed’ as a separate undertaking, even if you believe the information is already elsewhere in your bid. Health and safety plans in particular often contain a declaration whose absence is threatened with nullity. An internal checklist ticking off every signature box in the specifications costs less than a lost contract. And do not expect equal treatment with a competitor whose defect is of a different kind: an omitted price can be remedied by the authority, a missing declaration cannot. For contracting authorities: state the nullity sanction clearly in the form itself and explain in the evaluation report why a defect is substantial. A clear distinction between remediable arithmetic errors and irremediable declaration defects makes your decision resistant to a charge of unequal treatment.
Ask yourself
Have you actually completed, dated and signed every page of the health and safety plan that the specifications describe as ‘to be completed and signed’? Do you sometimes assume that information elsewhere in your bid makes a requested form unnecessary? Do you know the distinction the regulations draw between an omitted unit price (remediable by the authority) and a missing declaration or undertaking? As a contracting authority: is the nullity sanction stated unequivocally in your forms, and does your evaluation report explain why a defect is substantial? As a contracting authority: can you justify why you make an arithmetic correction for one bidder and reject another’s bid?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →