Rejection French-speaking chamber

Twelve non-conformity reports, 40 points out of 100: Construct Time loses ‘its’ Namur meter lot, and the Council of State refuses to reweigh the points itself

Ruling nr. 210655 · 24 January 2011 · VIe kamer (kort geding)

The Walloon distribution intermunicipal companies were entitled not to select the incumbent contractor Construct Time for the lot ‘meters and connections in the Namur region’ because, after twelve non-conformity reports, it had only 40 of 100 points left in its current contract, whereas the contract notice required at least 65%: according to the Council of State, such a selection criterion based on past performance is permissible, adequately reasoned and not a disguised exclusion ground, and the dispute over the reports themselves belongs before the ordinary courts.

What happened?

In 2008 Construct Time had won contract CPTNA11164 from the Walloon distribution intermunicipal companies: the installation and replacement of prepayment meters and of remote-control receivers for electricity meters at residential customers in the Namur region. The contract was extended by mutual agreement until 30 June 2011, because the follow-up procedure had been delayed. That follow-up was announced on 14 July 2010 in the Official Journal of the European Union and in the Belgian Bulletin of Tenders: a framework agreement for connection works and works on meters and connections on the existing electricity and gas networks in the Walloon provinces, in 32 lots, estimated at 26,260,000 euros, to be performed from 1 July 2011 to 30 June 2012, through a negotiated procedure with publication in two stages (selection, then offers). Point VI.3, 8, of the notice stated that only companies that had obtained ‘at least 65% of the points’ and had not received two default reports (‘PV de carence’) in the current contract, or one closed less than 24 months earlier, for the same region and field would be considered. The specifications of the current contracts (CCA3) set out the arithmetic: each contract starts at 100 points, each confirmed non-conformity report costs 5 points, each default report 20. Construct Time applied for lots 1 to 5. By letter of 17 December 2010, ORES, on behalf of the intermunicipal companies IDEG, IEH, IGH, Interest, Interlux, Intermosane, Sedilec and Simogel, notified Construct Time that it had not been selected for lot 5 (E1, Namur region): its points balance for contract CPTNA11164 stood at 40 out of 100. It was selected for lots 1 (Charleroi), 2 (Mons), 3 (Tournai-Mouscron) and 4 (Walloon Brabant). Construct Time requested the minutes of the decision by fax on 21 December 2010 and through its lawyers on 27 December 2010; ORES provided them on 28 December 2010, and the application for suspension under extreme urgency followed on 30 December 2010. Construct Time had received twelve non-conformity reports. Six concerned the travel of a site manager when Construct Time had been told the day before that the job was cancelled; five concerned the absence of an aerial lift on site. According to Construct Time these were trifles that had not been invoiced, no default report or evaluation report had ever followed, and the extension of its contract in November 2010 showed precisely that the intermunicipal companies were satisfied. Acting president Paul Lewalle first dealt with the objections. The action against a ‘possible’ award decision lacked an object, as the award stage had not yet begun. Construct Time’s representation by its managing director Stéphane Nizet, though ‘not free of ambiguity’, was prima facie in order. Construct Time had an interest, had acted with the required diligence and did not need to challenge the notice beforehand. ORES was not removed from the case, as it had played an active role in informing the candidate. On the merits, the single plea failed in all three of its limbs. The 65-point criterion rested on objective rules published in the notice and the specifications, as article 16(2) of the Royal Decree of 10 January 1996 requires; it was not disproportionate given the subject-matter of the contract and did not breach equality, since candidates that had not been party to the previous contract were not prevented from competing. The statement of reasons referred to the criterion and to the points balance, and the method of calculation was in the specifications; it was therefore adequate. And Construct Time did not show that this was a disguised exclusion ground outside article 17: it was a selection criterion based on the candidate’s track record. What Construct Time was really contesting — the seriousness of the shortcomings alleged and the score of 40 out of 100 — concerns the performance of the contract and therefore civil rights, which under article 144 of the Constitution are exclusively for the courts, even when raised against a detachable act such as the selection decision. The application was dismissed; the costs of 175 euros were borne by Construct Time. First auditor and head of section Derouaux had advised to the same effect.

Why does this matter?

The judgment addresses a question that matters to every incumbent contractor: may a contracting authority let poor marks from the current contract weigh in the selection for the next one? The Council of State answers, prima facie, yes, provided the criterion is objective, set out in advance in the notice and based on a knowable calculation. It sees it not as a disguised exclusion ground but as a selection criterion based on track record, and it sees no unequal treatment of newcomers who compete without a history. The logic of the lots is striking: the same contractor can be found suitable for Charleroi, Mons, Tournai-Mouscron and Walloon Brabant, and still miss out in Namur, precisely where it was the incumbent. The second, perhaps more important point is procedural. The real battle was over the reports: were a wasted trip and a missing aerial lift really non-conformities? The Council leaves that question aside, because it concerns the performance of the contract and therefore belongs to the ordinary courts. A contractor that wants to defend its points must do so during performance, and if need be before the civil courts — not only before the Council of State once non-selection is a fact. The fact that the authority extended the contract in the meantime changes nothing.

The lesson

For contractors performing a current contract: read the non-conformity and points-deduction rules in your specifications as a selection rule for the next contract. Contest every non-conformity report immediately, in writing and with reasons, and do not assume that an extension of your contract or the absence of a default report proves that all is well. If you want to challenge the points themselves, that is a dispute about performance, which belongs before the ordinary courts; the Council of State will not reweigh them. Read the contract notice carefully too: if it contains a selection threshold based on past performance, you know in advance where you stand. For contracting authorities: a selection criterion based on performance in previous contracts can stand, provided it is objective, published in advance, linked to the same region and field, and its calculation is set out in the contract documents. Give reasons for non-selection with the concrete points balance and a reference to the criterion.

Ask yourself

Do you know how many points you still have in your current contracts, and whether the notice for the next contract links a selection threshold to them? Do you contest every non-conformity report immediately and in writing, knowing that it may later cost you your selection? Do you realise that the Council of State does not rule on whether reports issued during the performance of a contract were justified, and that you must go to the ordinary courts for that? Did you request the minutes of a non-selection decision straight away, so that you can respond within the fifteen-day time limit? As a contracting authority: is the calculation of your performance points set out in the contract documents, and is the selection criterion included in the notice in advance and limited to the same region and field?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →