Annulment French-speaking chamber

The cheapest bidder ends up third with 18 out of 70 and nobody explains why: Council of State annuls the award of the sports equipment for the Couvin sports hall because a table of points is not a statement of reasons

Ruling nr. 211136 · 9 February 2011 · VIe kamer

Technic-Floor offered the lowest price, 120,807.02 euros, for the sports equipment of the Couvin sports hall but finished third behind Sporta De Waele; the Council of State annulled the award because the report relied on by the intercommunal consisted only of tables of points without any justification, and neither an explanatory note drawn up after the decision nor a letter with the breakdown of points could cure that defect.

What happened?

The Association intercommunale des sports du sud-Namurois et du sud-Hainaut, based in Couvin, wanted to equip its new sports hall in Couvin. On 17 November 2008 its board approved specifications no. 08.N10 of 29 September 2008, with an overall estimate of 251,587.60 euros excluding VAT, under a general call for tenders. The contract had two lots: lot 1 for the sports equipment, lot 2 for fitting out a climbing hall with a curtain wall. Lot 1 had six award criteria, together worth 250 points: price (80), compliance with the required technical characteristics (70), delivery period (40), quality and finish of the materials (30), compliance with standards (20) and scope and duration of the guarantee (10). The specifications used a ranking formula: the first-ranked tenderer received the maximum per criterion, the others that maximum minus (position minus one) times the points divided by the number of candidates, rounded up. Four tenders came in for lot 1: Technic-Floor of Angleur at 120,807.02 euros, Sporta De Waele of Zele at 127,584.29 euros, Allard Sport of Virton at 141,258 euros and Idemma Sport of Thimister at 146,375.13 euros, all excluding VAT. In his reports of 20 March 2009 the designer, Jean-Pierre Noël, proposed awarding lot 1 to Sporta De Waele: it scored 220 points, Technic-Floor 166, placing it third. On 23 March 2009 the board awarded lot 1 to Sporta De Waele for 127,584.29 euros and lot 2 to Idemma Sport for 122,356.22 euros, and ordered delivery within the 30 working days of the specifications, ‘in view of the inauguration scheduled for 7 May’. Lot 2 was not challenged. On 24 March Technic-Floor received a letter saying its tender had not been chosen, without any mention of the available remedies. On 27 March it asked for the detailed comparison. The reply of 6 April 2009 confirmed third place and gave its own points: 80 out of 80 for price, 18 out of 70 for technical characteristics, 40 out of 40 for the delivery period, 8 out of 30 for quality and finish, 10 out of 20 for standards and 10 out of 10 for the guarantee. On 25 May 2009 Technic-Floor applied for annulment of the award of lot 1. The intercommunal first contested admissibility. The Council held that the time limit had never started to run, because the letter of 24 March lacked the information required by Article 19, second paragraph, of the coordinated laws on the Council of State; the application was in any event timely. Being third did not deprive Technic-Floor of its interest: anyone who took part in the procedure has, according to the Council, a sufficient moral interest in having the lawfulness of the rejection of its tender reviewed. The intercommunal also argued that the tender contained many passages in English, contrary to the specifications. But it had not found that irregularity when examining the tenders, and therefore could not raise it for the first time before the Council. On the merits, Technic-Floor complained that it could not understand why it had received 18 out of 70, 8 out of 30 and 10 out of 20. The Council found that the award decision referred to the report of 20 March 2009, and that this report consisted solely of tables with the points per tenderer and per item, without a single score being accompanied by any justification. An ‘explanatory note’ from the intercommunal was dated 10 July 2009, after the contested decision, and therefore did not count. Nor could the letter of 6 April make up for the deficient reasoning of the decision itself: the formal duty to state reasons applies to the decision, not to the letters that communicate it. The Council concluded that awarding points per criterion and the resulting ranking do not show why the authority made precisely that choice. A decision based solely on those points and that ranking is not adequately reasoned. On 9 February 2011 the VIth chamber, presided by chamber president Odile Daurmont and on the report of Councillor of State Paul Lewalle, annulled the award of lot 1 to Sporta De Waele, in line with the concurring opinion of first auditor Thibaut. The costs, 175 euros, were borne by the intercommunal.

Why does this matter?

The judgment applies a principle that keeps recurring in later case law: points are not reasons. A table of scores tells a tenderer how many points it got, but not why. A bidder that, like Technic-Floor, submitted the cheapest tender and still ended up third must be able to tell from the decision, or the report on which it relies, what was lacking in its technical characteristics, materials and standards. It is also striking how the Council closes off the authority’s lines of defence one by one. An explanatory note drawn up after the decision does not count. A letter with the breakdown of points is not a statement of reasons for the decision itself. And an irregularity in the tender, here the English passages, that the authority did not identify during the evaluation cannot be brought up for the first time in proceedings before the Council. The judgment also confirms two procedural points that remain useful for unsuccessful bidders: a notification that does not mention the available remedies does not start the time limit, and a tenderer that finished third rather than second keeps its interest. The inauguration scheduled for 7 May explains why the intercommunal was in a hurry; it does not explain why the points were left unexplained.

The lesson

For contracting authorities: give reasons for every score on the qualitative criteria in the evaluation report itself, with concrete references to what each tender offered or lacked, and finish that report before the decision is taken. An explanation drawn up afterwards, or given only in a letter to the unsuccessful bidder, does not save the decision. If you find an irregularity, state it in the decision; otherwise you cannot rely on it later. And mention the available remedies in the notification, or the time limit will not run. For bidders: third place is no reason to forgo an appeal if the reasoning is no more than a table of points. Ask for the reasoned award decision immediately after notification, and check whether each score is justified. If it is not, you have a strong ground, even if you were the cheapest and got full marks on price.

Ask yourself

As an authority: is every score in your evaluation report backed by a concrete justification, or only by a number? Is the report finished when the decision is taken? Does the decision mention the irregularities you identify in tenders? Does your notification to unsuccessful bidders state the available remedies and time limits? As a bidder: have you requested the reasoned award decision and the report, and not only your own points? Can you tell from those documents why you lost points on each qualitative criterion? Do you know that a missing statement of remedies can keep the time limit open?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →