Electro Belux claims the full profit on an annulled award for meal trolleys and gets nothing: an all-or-nothing claim cannot be patched with a late loss-of-chance claim
After the Council of State annulled the award by the CPAS of Binche of a contract for meal distribution trolleys to G.B.M., the unsuccessful bidder Electro Belux claimed EUR 39,209.80 in compensation as its full lost profit, but the Council rejected the claim because it rested on factually incorrect premises and it could not be established who would have won the contract under a proper assessment — and the loss-of-chance claim it raised only in its final brief came too late, even though the CPAS itself had offered 6 per cent of the tender price.
What happened?
The CPAS (public social welfare centre) of Binche put out a supply contract for meal distribution trolleys (hot and cold line) for the Résidence Jeanne Mertens. On 24 April 2024 it awarded the contract to G.B.M. Electro Belux, one of the bidders, went to the Council of State. By judgment no. 260.309 of 27 June 2024, the Council suspended the award under the extreme-urgency procedure: the trolleys offered by G.B.M. and by Cuisimat departed from the specifications on several points — a top that was not stainless steel, doors protruding beyond the chassis when open, 160 mm instead of 200 mm wheels, flat instead of inclined tanks, and, for Cuisimat, trolleys with 20 and 24 trays instead of 16 and a power rating of 6.4 kW instead of a maximum of 5.1 kW. None of these deviations was mentioned in the evaluation report or the award decision. The CPAS argued that only the trolley width was a minimum requirement, but the Council held that other specifications — partly through the Q&A forum — could have that character too, and that it was for the contracting authority to examine and classify the deviations first. As the CPAS and G.B.M. did not respond further, the Council annulled the award by judgment no. 262.576 of 11 March 2025. On 10 April 2025 Electro Belux sought compensation under Article 11bis of the coordinated laws on the Council of State. Its reasoning: had its tender been declared regular, it would have been ranked first and won the contract; its loss was therefore not a lost chance but the full lost profit. Its calculation: tender price EUR 190,636 excl. VAT, minus EUR 7,680 for maintenance, gives EUR 182,956 turnover; minus EUR 143,746.20 purchase price from the manufacturer, gives EUR 39,209.80, plus interest from 8 May 2024. The CPAS disputed causation: the annulment judgment had never held that the G.B.M. and Cuisimat tenders had to be excluded. It conceded at most a lost chance and proposed limiting compensation to a flat 6 per cent of the tender, i.e. EUR 10,976.76 excl. VAT, since price was not the only award criterion. Electro Belux maintained its full-profit claim and only in its final brief asked, in the alternative, for 50 per cent on account of an ‘extremely high’ chance. The Council of State rejected the claim in full. First, it found that the claim rested on manifestly incorrect facts: the annulled award decision had not declared Electro Belux’s tender irregular but had simply ranked it, neither the evaluation report nor the award decision had ranked it first, and its price was not the most advantageous. Second, the annulment judgment had not declared the deviations in the G.B.M. and Cuisimat tenders substantial; it had only said the CPAS had to classify them itself. It was therefore impossible to determine to whom the contract would have been awarded under a lawful assessment, so the assertion that Electro Belux would ‘necessarily’ have won could not stand. The alternative loss-of-chance claim, raised for the first time in the final brief, was a different claim from the original one and was declared inadmissible as out of time. Electro Belux bears the costs: EUR 200 court fee, EUR 26 contribution and EUR 770 procedural indemnity to the CPAS.
Why does this matter?
The judgment shows how an annulment won on the merits can still be lost in compensation proceedings because of how the claim is built. Electro Belux had an annulment in hand and the contracting authority itself conceded that a chance had been lost — the CPAS offered 6 per cent of the tender. Yet the case ends at zero. The reasons are both substantive and procedural. Substantively: an annulment for failing to examine competing tenders does not prove that those tenders had to be excluded, and therefore not that the applicant would have won. Whoever nonetheless claims the full lost profit must establish that causal link — and here the factual premises (first place, best price, a tender declared irregular) did not match the file. Procedurally: a lost chance is a different head of damage from full lost profit, and raising it only in the final brief is too late. The judgment fits a series of recent Article 11bis rulings in which the Council scrutinises causation and the assessment of chances closely, and it is a reminder that compensation is not an automatic sequel to an annulment.
The lesson
If, as an unsuccessful bidder, you seek compensation after an annulment, structure your claim in layers from the initial application: principally the full lost profit if you can genuinely show you would have won, and expressly in the alternative the loss of a chance, with a reasoned percentage. Whatever you add only in the final brief no longer counts. Check every factual assertion against the file: claiming to have been ranked first or to have offered the best price when the documents show otherwise costs you credibility and the case. Read carefully why the award was annulled: a failure to examine or state reasons regarding competitors yields at most a chance, not certainty. For contracting authorities the lesson is twofold: an annulment for unexamined deviations from the specifications is avoidable by naming and classifying every deviation in the evaluation report; and in compensation proceedings it pays to contest causation precisely rather than merely negotiating the amount.
Ask yourself
Does your compensation application also set out, from the start, an alternative claim for loss of a chance with a reasoned percentage? Does every factual premise of your claim — ranking, price, regularity of your tender — match the evaluation report and the award decision? Have you checked whether the annulment judgment actually declared the competing tenders irregular, or merely held that the contracting authority still had to examine them? Is your lost-profit calculation defensible (tender price minus all costs), and can you support the figures with documents? As a contracting authority: does your evaluation report name and classify every deviation from the specifications in all tenders, including specifications not printed in bold as minimum requirements?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →