Rejection Dutch-speaking chamber

Podcast series for AZ Sint-Jan Bruges: invoking article 36 of the Royal Decree on award below the EU threshold means pleading a provision that does not apply

Ruling nr. 266878 · 2 June 2026 · XIVe kamer

D.P. BV sought, under extreme urgency, the suspension of AZ Sint-Jan Bruges’s award of a contract for a podcast series with video recording on prevention and health, but the Council of State dismissed the application: the abnormal-price review of article 36 of the Royal Decree on award and the reasoning rules of articles 4, 7 and 8 of the Remedies Act do not apply to a negotiated procedure without prior publication below the EU threshold, a suspicion of abnormal prices without any beginning of proof is not enough, and calculation errors that do not change the ranking give no standing to raise the plea.

What happened?

AZ Sint-Jan Bruges, an autonomous healthcare institution, put out a public services contract for the ‘production of a podcast series with video recording on prevention and health’. Because the estimated value was below the EU threshold, the hospital opted for a negotiated procedure without prior publication under article 42, § 1, 1°, a), of the Act of 17 June 2016. Four bidders submitted a tender. On 5 May 2026 the executive committee decided to award the contract to a bidder other than D.P. BV, which the very next day, 6 May 2026, applied for suspension under extreme urgency. The case was argued on 27 May 2026 before presiding judge Geert Debersaques. As a preliminary point, the Council noted that the application contained no summary of the pleas, only a list of the provisions allegedly infringed. Since the Royal Decree of 21 July 2023 such a summary is mandatory; its absence does not make a plea inadmissible, but the applicant must then accept that the Council understands the complaints as it reads them. In the first plea, D.P. BV criticised the hospital’s inadequate reasoning in accepting the price justification of the chosen bidder, relying on article 36 of the Royal Decree on award of 18 April 2017 and on articles 4, 7 and 8 of the Act of 17 June 2013. Both bases fell away: under article 36, § 6, of the Royal Decree, article 36 does not apply to a negotiated procedure without prior publication below the EU threshold unless the procurement documents provide otherwise, and under articles 29, § 1, and 29/1 of the Act of 17 June 2013, articles 4, 7 and 8 do not apply to contracts below the threshold. The complaint of an ‘asymmetry’ — detailed reasoning when a tender is rejected, a standard formula when an exceptionally low price is accepted — was found insufficiently developed. A reliance on article 35 of the Royal Decree raised only at the hearing gave the plea a different scope and was disregarded. In the second plea, D.P. BV argued that the unit prices had not been examined at all. Its only indication was that a section of the award report bore the heading ‘review of abnormal unit prices and total tender prices’, while the text contained only a table of deviations from the total tender prices. For the Council that was not enough: the award report stated that all tenders had undergone a price review under article 35, the administrative file confirmed this, and for intellectual services, which appear to leave bidders a wider margin in pricing, the contracting authority has broad discretion to accept prices as normal. Anyone claiming otherwise must make it plausible with concrete evidence. In the third plea, D.P. BV pointed to three arithmetical errors in the evaluation report as a sign of carelessness. The hospital objected that those errors did not affect the ranking, and the applicant did not respond to this at the hearing. The Council agreed with the hospital: even after correction, the errors prima facie changed nothing in the ranking, so they did not prejudice the applicant within the meaning of article 14 of the Act of 17 June 2013. The plea was inadmissible. None of the pleas was serious; the application was dismissed.

Why does this matter?

The judgment exposes a trap that is often overlooked in smaller contracts: below the EU threshold, in a negotiated procedure without prior publication, much of the legal framework on which unsuccessful bidders usually rely disappears. The detailed abnormal-price review of article 36 of the Royal Decree on award does not apply unless the procurement documents impose it, and neither do the specific reasoning and information duties of the Remedies Act. What remains is the general price review of article 35, the Formal Reasoning Act of 29 July 1991 and the principles of good administration. An application built entirely on article 36 then collapses on an ‘incorrect legal premise’. The Council also sharpens three procedural lines. The summary of pleas is not a formality: whoever omits it loses control over how the complaint is read. A new legal basis invoked only at the hearing does not count. And calculation errors in an award report matter only if they can change the ranking. Finally, the judgment confirms that, for intellectual services — here creative audiovisual production — the contracting authority has wide latitude to accept low prices as normal, and that the burden of proving otherwise lies with the complainant.

The lesson

Bidders: before drafting an application, check which procedure and which estimated value the contract has. Below the EU threshold and without prior publication you cannot rely on article 36 of the Royal Decree on award or on articles 4, 7 and 8 of the Remedies Act, unless the specifications expressly make them applicable — build your plea on article 35, on the Act of 29 July 1991 and on the duty of care instead. If you suspect an abnormally low price, provide concrete evidence, not assumptions based on a heading in the award report. Write a genuine summary for each plea, invoke every legal basis in the application itself, and raise calculation errors only if you can show they change your ranking. Contracting authorities: state expressly in the award report that all tenders were subjected to a price review under article 35 and make sure the administrative file supports it; watch your headings (a heading ‘abnormal unit prices’ above a table that only compares total prices invites challenge) and check your report’s arithmetic, even though the standing rules saved you here.

Ask yourself

Do you know which provisions of the Royal Decree on award and of the Remedies Act still apply to a negotiated procedure without prior publication below the EU threshold? Do your specifications expressly make the abnormal-price review of article 36 of the Royal Decree applicable, or not? Can you support a suspicion of abnormally low prices with concrete evidence, or does it rest on assumptions? Does your application contain a genuine summary of the complaint for each plea, and does it already include every legal basis you want to invoke? Do the errors you point out in the award report change anything in the ranking? As a contracting authority: do the headings in your award report match what is underneath, and does the file show that the price review actually took place?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →