Rejection Dutch-speaking chamber

Lanaken tennis hall: a long lease with a use clause and a business plan is not yet a services concession — and losing that chance creates no extreme urgency

Ruling nr. 266911 · 4 June 2026 · XIVe kamer

BV A. challenged AGB Lanaken’s award of a thirty-year long lease (erfpacht) on the municipal tennis hall to vzw T. (90 to 65 points), arguing that it was really a services concession, but the Council of State saw, prima facie, an ordinary long lease without enforceable operating requirements, therefore applied the ordinary suspension conditions and dismissed the application because the mere loss of the chance to obtain that lease does not show extreme urgency.

What happened?

On 14 November 2013 the municipality of Lanaken granted its sports infrastructure, including the indoor tennis hall at Engelse Hof 20, on a 99-year long lease to the Autonomous Municipal Company (AGB) Lanaken. On 14 October 2025 the AGB’s executive committee decided it would no longer invest in the hall: it would be put on the market in its current state through a public market consultation, after which the chosen operator would receive a property right allowing it to act as ‘owner’ and invest itself. After approvals by the executive committee, the board of mayor and aldermen and the municipal council (15 December 2025), the AGB’s board launched the ‘market consultation for a long lease on the Lanaken tennis hall’ on 20 January 2026. The consultation file stated expressly that this was a long lease and not a public contract, but that the award would be open and transparent. The lease ran for thirty years, renewable once, with tennis and padel as the sole main use. There were four award criteria of 25 points each: a plan to involve Lanaken residents and the local tennis and padel club, references, the annual lease fee (at least 12,000 euros, indexed) and a business plan. All investments, maintenance, taxes and operating costs were for the lessee. Two candidates applied. vzw T. scored 90 points with a fee of 12,012 euros a year; BV A. scored 65 points despite offering 14,000 euros. On 21 April 2026 the executive committee awarded the lease to vzw T. BV A. requested withdrawal on 28 April, the AGB refused any further discussion on 4 May, and on 6 May BV A. applied for suspension under extreme urgency. The AGB objected that BV A. was challenging only the notification and not the decision itself. That objection was rejected: the application made sufficiently clear that the decision of 21 April 2026 was targeted. The core question was then whether BV A. could rely on the more favourable remedies regime of the Act of 17 June 2013, which requires a public contract or a concession. BV A. argued that the market consultation was in reality a services concession within the meaning of article 2, 7°, b), of the Concessions Act of 17 June 2016: its core was the operation of sports infrastructure and a cafeteria, the operator bore the operating risk, and the AGB steered the operation through the award criteria. State Councillor Inge Vos did not accept that requalification. The label ‘long lease’ is not decisive, but the decisive feature of a services concession is that it mainly concerns services meeting requirements set by the authority, whose performance the authority can enforce. That did not appear prima facie here. A use clause (tennis and padel) can also be stipulated in an ordinary long lease, as article 3.167 of the Civil Code allows. The approach plan and the business plan came from the candidates themselves, without minimum standards or enforceable obligations imposed by the AGB. Nothing was imposed regarding prices, access for residents or opening hours, and there was no monitoring or sanction mechanism. The contractual principles resembled the classic lease clauses that recital 15 of Directive 2014/23 expressly places outside the concept of a concession. The argument on operating risk therefore did not need to be examined further. The first plea was not serious; the Concessions Act and the Act of 17 June 2013 did not appear to apply, so the ordinary conditions of article 17 of the coordinated laws governed. BV A. did not meet those conditions. Acting diligently is necessary but not sufficient. The fact that the AGB could execute the lease deed at any moment does not in itself show urgency. Losing the chance to obtain the lease is a risk inherent in any market consultation: ‘the applicant does not lose a right of long lease; it simply is not granted one’. BV A. also produced no evidence at all about its professional situation or the concrete harm. The application was dismissed. BV A. bears the 200-euro roll fee, the 26-euro contribution and a procedural indemnity of 770 euros payable to the AGB.

Why does this matter?

Local authorities increasingly bring sports halls, catering pavilions and other municipal infrastructure to market through a long lease or building right with a ‘market consultation’ rather than a tender. This judgment shows where the line lies, prima facie. A long lease becomes a services concession only if the authority has services performed according to requirements it can itself enforce. A use clause, a minimum fee and qualitative criteria such as a business plan or a plan for cooperation with the local club are not enough, as long as the authority imposes no standards on prices, opening hours, access or monitoring. The consequences of that classification are significant. If the transaction falls outside the Concessions Act, it also falls outside the Act of 17 June 2013: no mandatory standstill period, no suspension ‘without proof of urgency’, but the strict ordinary extreme-urgency test. And that is where an unsuccessful candidate almost inevitably stumbles, because missing out on a chance is not serious, irreversible harm. Together with the judgment on the summer bar in Hemiksem (267005), this forms a clear line: anyone who misses out on a right of use over public property must show concrete, documented harm. The judgment is, however, a provisional ruling in summary proceedings and leaves open the question of the value of the alleged concession.

The lesson

Candidates: if you want a long lease or concession requalified, set out concretely in your application which enforceable operating requirements the authority imposes (prices, opening hours, access, reporting, sanctions) and why they form the centre of gravity. Operating risk only comes into play once that first point convinces. Assume, moreover, that the ordinary extreme-urgency test applies, and document the concrete consequences for your business with evidence: share of turnover, investments made, staff, contracts that depend on the award. ‘I am missing a chance’ or ‘the contract lasts thirty years’ is not enough. Local authorities and municipal companies: a property transaction with an open market consultation, a use clause and qualitative criteria remains, prima facie, outside the Concessions Act, as long as you are not ordering services with enforceable requirements. If you do want to fix prices, opening hours or social performance, realise that you are moving towards a services concession, with the attendant rules on publication, estimation and standstill. In any case, word your award criteria transparently: in the Asse case (259754) a long lease fell on vaguely described policy objectives.

Ask yourself

Does the authority in your file impose enforceable requirements on the operation (prices, opening hours, access, monitoring, sanctions), or only a use and a fee? As a candidate, can you show with evidence what concrete, irreversible harm you suffer if you miss out on the lease or concession? Do you know that the special remedies of the Act of 17 June 2013 (standstill period, suspension without proof of urgency) apply only to public contracts and concessions? Did your application challenge the actual decision, and not just its notification? As a local authority: have you consciously chosen between a pure property transaction and a services concession, and do your contractual principles fit that choice? As a local authority: are your qualitative award criteria described clearly enough for the market consultation to be transparent?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →