Other French-speaking chamber

Walloon Region calls off screen tender after withdrawing two awards: a bidder who stays out of the new procedure still keeps its interest in challenging the cancellation

Ruling nr. 266991 · 12 June 2026 · VIe kamer

After the Walloon Region twice awarded lot 1 (interactive LED screens for schools) to ESI Informatique, withdrew both awards following extreme-urgency applications by Davin (now Koesio), and finally decided not to award and to start again with new specifications, the Council of State held that Davin did not lose its interest in challenging that cancellation by not taking part in the new procedure, but declared the action against the ‘implicit refusal’ inadmissible and found it unproven that the new specifications made bidding impossible; the proceedings are reopened on the reasons for the cancellation.

What happened?

On 10 February 2020 the Walloon Region, acting as a central purchasing body, launched an open procedure for a framework agreement for the supply, installation and provision of educational IT equipment in Walloon schools, estimated at 11.5 million euros and divided into eight lots: from 75-inch interactive LED screens (lot 1) and mobile stands to mini PCs, Lego Education Spike Prime kits, scanners, Wi-Fi access points and micro:bits. Each lot was to be awarded on the best price-quality ratio: 50 points for price and 50 for technical quality, assessed through ten elements (A to J) in decreasing order of importance, without a weighting per element. On 4 May 2020 sixteen offers were received, eleven of them for lots 1 and 2, including from SA Davin, SRL ESI Informatique and SRL Defilangues. On 5 August 2020 the Region awarded lot 1 to ESI Informatique (81.25/100); Davin came second (78.84/100). Davin brought an action for annulment and an extreme-urgency application on 21 August 2020. On 10 September 2020 the Region withdrew the award in view of the third limb of Davin’s plea, which argued that an award sub-criterion had been distorted. A new decision of 17 December 2020 again awarded the lot to ESI Informatique, now with 85.88/100 against 81.75 for Davin. Davin went back to the Council of State on 4 January 2021; on 8 February 2021 the Region withdrew that award too, because the reasoning had to be reviewed and supplemented ‘in particular as regards the formal and substantive regularity of the offers’. In both proceedings the Council later held that there was no longer any need to rule (judgments no. 250.421 of 26 March 2021 and no. 253.684 of 9 May 2022). On 22 April 2021 the minister decided, under article 85 of the Act of 17 June 2016, not to award lot 1 and to start a new open procedure: some award sub-criteria were to become technical specifications, they had to be clarified, their hierarchy reviewed and preferably weighted. On 25 May 2021 a new notice was published for a framework agreement for 75-inch interactive LED screens, estimated at 2 million euros, with new specifications: 50 points for price, 35 for technical quality (ergonomics and software in a school context 20, screen quality 10, optional connectivity 5) and 15 for speed of intervention and warranty extension. On 23 June 2021 Davin wrote to the Region that it had adopted specifications that ‘de facto’ prevented it from bidding and were ‘geared’ towards the company the Region had ‘manifestly’ chosen; it did not bid. On 22 June 2021 it had already sought annulment of the cancellation decision, of the ‘implicit decision’ not to award the contract to it, and of the new specifications. On 25 June 2021 four offers were received, including from ESI Informatique and Defilangues; two were rejected because their screen did not meet the new minimum brightness of 400 nits, and on 1 October 2021 the new contract went to ESI Informatique (84/100). The Region argued that Davin had lost its interest by not bidding, and claimed for the first time that its original offer was irregular anyway: a prohibited agreement with Defilangues, a company in the same group whose offer had been signed by the same person, and signature by someone without authority to represent it. The deputy auditor-general considered the action wholly inadmissible, notably because Davin had not extended it to the final award of the new contract. The Council followed him only in part. On the cancellation decision: article 14 of the Act of 17 June 2013 only requires that the applicant has or has had an interest in obtaining the contract and has been or risks being harmed by the alleged infringements. Davin had bid for lot 1 and was challenging precisely the decision not to award that lot; not taking part in the new procedure does not change that. Moreover, the withdrawal of 8 February 2021 had announced only a review of the reasoning, not a cancellation; the cancellation deprived Davin of a fresh assessment of its offer under possibly more favourable conditions, and deficient formal reasoning can harm it in its own right. The Council distinguished the case from the Fedimmo judgment (no. 257.985), in which the applicant had expressly ‘chosen’ not to challenge the new procedure, and from CJEU judgments C-53/22 and C-328/17, which concerned award decisions. It would be excessive to require Davin to compete in a procedure whose launch it is challenging, or to extend its action to the new award. The contrary General Assembly judgment no. 129.101 of 10 March 2004 predates article 14 of the 2013 Act, which within its scope replaced the requirement of a current interest under article 19 of the coordinated laws: that the contract has since been awarded, concluded or even performed is therefore irrelevant. The new irregularities the Region raised in the proceedings had never been found during the award procedure, and the Council refused to substitute its assessment for the authority’s. On the ‘implicit refusal’ the Council was stricter: such a refusal presupposes an award to a competitor, and after the cancellation there was none. Davin’s claim that, after correcting three material errors, it should have scored 86.74/100 rested largely on the first evaluation grid the Region itself had already withdrawn; moreover, Davin did not claim that the Region was barred in any event from cancelling. That part was declared inadmissible. On the new specifications: under the CJEU’s Marina del Mediterráneo case law such a decision is open to challenge, but a party that did not bid must show that the conditions made an offer impossible or illusory. Many complaints were raised only in the last brief and were out of time. For the two remaining specifications, the proof failed. The requirement of side-only connectors (with the option to reject screens with front connectors because of the ‘risk of being torn out’ in schools) did not prevent four bidders with different brands from bidding, and Davin itself had written in its second extreme-urgency application that it had screens with ‘connectors on the side only’; it produced no catalogue showing otherwise. The requirement of ‘integrated only’ wireless connectivity (Bluetooth 4.0, Wi-Fi 802.11ac and screen mirroring) was no obstacle either: Davin’s screen already had integrated Bluetooth, and on Wi-Fi it had itself written that it would have ‘fixed’ its antenna to the screen had it known that the USB dongle would cost it 2.5 points. The action against the specifications is therefore not admissible on the basis of the third plea; its admissibility still depends on the first plea. Because the auditor had not examined that first plea, directed against the reasons for the cancellation, the Council reopened the proceedings and asked for a supplementary report. The offers remain confidential; costs are reserved.

Why does this matter?

The judgment is a statement of principle on standing to challenge a decision not to award a contract and to restart the procedure. The Council makes clear that under article 14 of the 2013 Remedies Act all that counts is whether the applicant has or has had an interest in obtaining the contract and may be harmed by the alleged illegality. The older test under article 19 of the coordinated laws — a current and continuing interest, with the prospect of a concrete benefit from annulment — no longer applies in that context. A bidder challenging the cancellation therefore need not also compete in the new procedure, and does not lose its interest because the new contract has meanwhile been awarded or even performed. In doing so, the Council expressly departs from the line of the 2004 General Assembly judgment. At the same time, the judgment draws two clear limits. A party challenging the ‘implicit refusal’ to award to it must show that the authority had no choice but to award to it, which is virtually impossible without an award decision in favour of a competitor and with a withdrawn evaluation. And a party challenging the new specifications without bidding must prove that the conditions made an offer impossible or illusory. Your own procedural documents can then work against you: Davin was confronted with its own statements in an earlier extreme-urgency application. For authorities, the judgment is also a reminder that irregularities in an offer that were never established in the award procedure itself cannot be raised afterwards before the Council to contest the applicant’s standing.

The lesson

For bidders: if an authority abandons the award and starts again after your challenge, you can contest that cancellation without having to take part in the new procedure. But if you also want to attack the new specifications, you must be able to prove that you genuinely could not bid: produce your catalogue, document why you could not meet or source a specification, and watch what you wrote earlier in your own pleadings. ‘The specifications favour my competitor’ is not enough if you could in fact have bid. Raise all your complaints in the application or at the latest in the reply: new complaints in the last brief are out of time. For authorities: if you withdraw an award decision to review its reasoning and then cancel the whole procedure, give careful reasons for that change of course; the Council is still examining those reasons. If you want to declare an offer irregular because of a prohibited agreement between related companies or a lack of signing authority, do so in the award procedure itself, not only in your reply brief. And when you rewrite specifications after a dispute, assess critically whether new requirements are objectively justified by the need, such as the risk of connectors being torn out in a classroom, rather than appearing tailored to one product.

Ask yourself

As a bidder: when an authority abandons the award and restarts, are you challenging the cancellation decision itself, and do you know you need not take part in the new procedure to do so? If you challenge the new specifications without bidding, can you show with documents that a specification made an offer impossible or illusory for you? Are the statements in your earlier applications consistent with what you now claim about your products? Are all your complaints in the application or the reply, and not only in the last brief? As an authority: does your decision to abandon the award explain concretely why you are not reassessing the existing offers? Have you examined and established possible irregularities in offers, such as prohibited agreements or signing authority, during the award procedure, rather than raising them only before the Council? Can you explain, for each new technical specification, which objective need it serves?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →