21,000 or 60,000 bolts? De Vlaamse Waterweg was entitled to reject a price justification that badly underestimated the number of bolts to be removed
The joint venture of NV D. and BV B. was 32.86% below the trimmed average for clearing a disused railway zone in Logistics Valley Flanders and assumed 21,000 bolts to be unscrewed in its price justification, whereas De Vlaamse Waterweg derived at least 60,000 from 10,000 sleepers with six bolts each; the Council of State held that this single ground already supported the rejection of the offer, that a new reading of the bidder’s own table (‘21,000 per worker’) and evidence on bolting machines first produced in the application came too late, and dismissed the extreme-urgency application.
What happened?
NV De Vlaamse Waterweg tendered a public works contract for clearing a disused railway zone on the Logistics Valley Flanders business park: a narrow strip of about 40,000 m² with old private shunting tracks in poor condition, to be fully dismantled and then backfilled and seeded. The bill of quantities followed the sequence of the works: item 1 for clearing shrubs and small trees, item 2 for ‘removing tracks and unscrewing bolts’ (estimated quantity 10,000 m), item 3 for ‘removing, disposing of and processing wooden railway sleepers’ (10,000 units), items 4 to 9 for excavating and removing the ballast, and items 10 and 11 for demolishing an access gate and a control cabin. Nine offers were received. Three bidders, including the joint venture of NV D. and BV B., were asked to justify their prices, notably the unit prices of item 2 and items 4 to 9 and the total offer amount. On 30 April 2026 De Vlaamse Waterweg awarded the contract to NV A. The award report did not accept the joint venture’s justification. For item 2 it assumed a ‘very high output’ per bolt and 21,000 bolts to be unscrewed; the authority pointed out that each sleeper has at least six bolts — visible on a photograph and on the site-visit photographs the bidder had itself attached to its offer — so that 10,000 sleepers mean at least 60,000 bolts. For the ballast, the authority found the difference in loading time, and hence in price per tonne, between item 4 and items 5 to 9 inexplicable, since the fractions are only separated at the processing site. The deviation of -32.86% from the trimmed average also remained unexplained. Together with its ATO department, De Vlaamse Waterweg decided to exclude the offer as substantially irregular. On 21 May 2026 the joint venture sought suspension under extreme urgency. The Council first found that each of the two price-related grounds could on its own support the exclusion, so the applicants had to defeat both. It started with item 2. The applicants argued that the 21,000 bolts in their table applied per worker, with a team of two workers and 116.67 hours, so some 42,000 bolts in total. The Council examined the confidential table and confirmed that it simply stated 21,000 bolts, with no mention of ‘per worker’. That reading was new, found no support in the text and was in any event at the bidder’s risk: whoever phrases an essential element of a price justification ambiguously cannot shift the consequences onto the authority, which need not invent alternative meanings itself. The complaint that the specifications nowhere said the number of bolts should be derived from item 3 was equally unconvincing: items 2 and 3 concern the same sleepers on the same stretch, and it was natural to link the number of bolts to the number of sleepers rather than to the length of track. The applicants only sought to substantiate the high output in their application, citing the use of two tirefonneuses (bolting machines), a video clip and a statement from a company not shown to be performing the work. That was an after-the-fact justification: those data should have been in the price justification itself. Because the item-2 ground stood and, according to the Council, even left the authority no choice but to exclude the offer (article 36, § 3, first paragraph, 1°, and article 76, § 3, of the Royal Decree of 18 April 2017), the applicants no longer had an interest in their criticism of the ballast items. Of its own motion, the Council also noted that De Vlaamse Waterweg had, on its own initiative, quoted in its brief from a document the applicants had asked to be kept confidential; they raised no objection at the hearing. The application was dismissed. The joint venture bears 400 euros in roll fees, a 26-euro contribution and a 770-euro procedural indemnity to De Vlaamse Waterweg; NV A. pays its 150-euro intervention fee.
Why does this matter?
The judgment neatly summarises the case law on price justification and shows how little room a bidder has once the authority finds one well-founded ground. Three points stand out. First, the burden of proof: it is for the bidder to rebut the presumption of abnormality concretely and fully, and the Council reviews the rejection only marginally. Second, clarity: a figure in a table is read as it stands. Saying afterwards that ‘21,000’ meant per worker is telling a new story, and an unclear price justification is a risk for the bidder, not the authority. Third, timing: technical evidence underpinning the price — here the bolting machines meant to explain the high output — belongs in the price justification, not in the application. On top of that, the Council applies the decisive-ground technique: if one ground for rejection stands, the bidder loses its interest in criticising the others. For authorities, the judgment confirms that they may derive quantities from related items of the bill of quantities, even if the specifications do not literally say so, as long as that reading follows from the context of the contract. And a small warning: quoting from a document the other side asked to keep confidential is best not done unilaterally.
The lesson
For bidders: treat a request for price justification as the moment your offer survives or falls. Write every figure so that it can be read only one way — state explicitly whether a quantity is per worker, per team or in total. Check your assumptions against the whole bill of quantities and against your own site visit: if your photographs show six bolts per sleeper, your calculation must too. Attach the technical evidence for an exceptional output (machines, references, subcontractors) to the justification straight away; what first appears in an extreme-urgency application no longer counts. And expect the authority to settle the matter with a single sustainable ground. For authorities: give reasons for the rejection item by item and concretely, with reference to the contract documents and, where possible, to what the bidder itself supplied. Two independent grounds, each sufficient on its own, make the decision robust. In the proceedings, respect the confidentiality the other party requested for its documents.
Ask yourself
As a bidder: can every figure in your price justification be read only one way, and does it say whether it is a total, a quantity per worker or per team? Have you checked the quantities in one item against related items of the bill of quantities and against your own findings during the site visit? Does your price rely on an exceptional output, and have you already included the machines, references or subcontractors that explain it in the justification itself? As an authority: does each of your grounds for rejection support the exclusion of the offer on its own, and is each concretely linked to the contract documents? Do you handle documents for which the other party requested confidential treatment carefully in your pleadings?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →