Rejection French-speaking chamber

A bidder who has the award suspended before the contract is signed loses no chance: CWS Workwear gets no 27,484.80 euros from Charleroi

Ruling nr. 267172 · 22 June 2026 · VIe kamer

In 2023 CWS Workwear obtained the suspension of the award of Charleroi’s workwear contract to Depairon, after which the city withdrew its decision and re-awarded the contract to Depairon — a second decision CWS left unchallenged; its claim for 27,484.80 euros in compensation for loss of a chance was held admissible but unfounded, because the suspension before the contract was concluded had precisely prevented the damage.

What happened?

On 21 February 2023 the city of Charleroi awarded public services contract no. 2022-33, for the rental and maintenance of workwear, to NV Depairon. NV CWS Workwear Belgie, whose offer had then been found regular and ranked second of three, challenged that decision. By judgment no. 256.336 of 24 April 2023, the Council of State suspended the award under extreme urgency because the city had unilaterally ‘rectified’ CWS’s prices. The award decision had not yet been notified to Depairon, so no contract was ever concluded on that basis. On 13 June 2023 the city executive withdrew the decision; the withdrawal was notified to the three bidders on 30 June 2023, stating the available remedies, and no one challenged it. On 18 July 2023 the city took a new decision: CWS’s offer was now declared irregular and the contract again went to Depairon. On 31 July 2023 CWS put the city on notice to withdraw that decision too; the city refused on 4 August. CWS brought no action against the new award. In its reply brief it wrote that it refrained for budgetary reasons, and because it did not know how many more times it would have to litigate to genuinely prevail. On 11 January 2024, however, CWS did file a claim for compensation of 27,484.80 euros plus interest. By judgment no. 259.070 of 8 March 2024 the Council reopened the proceedings and referred the case to the ordinary procedure. In the final judgment the Council first finds that the annulment action has lost its object through the definitive withdrawal. It still had to rule on the compensation claim. Charleroi disputed CWS’s interest: the withdrawal was reparation in kind, and CWS had had its full chance in the new evaluation of offers. The Council rejected that objection. Relying on the Moors judgment of the General Assembly (no. 244.015 of 22 March 2019), it held that the same logic applies where the authority withdraws the act, and that the interest in compensation follows from the claim to have suffered damage from the illegality; CWS need not additionally show an interest in a finding of illegality. On the merits, however, the claim failed. CWS argued that it lost a one-in-three chance at the moment of the contested decision and that later facts change nothing, relying on a Court of Cassation judgment of 26 January 2007. The Council disagreed: where an award is suspended or annulled before the contract is concluded, damage consisting in the loss of the contract or of a chance to obtain it is as a rule not established, because the suspension in itself prevents that damage from arising, save in special circumstances. The Cassation judgment concerned the termination of a contract for breach and is not transposable; moreover, the issue here was not the assessment of the damage but its very existence. The second award of 18 July 2023 is, in the Council’s view, unrelated to the finding that CWS lost no chance through the first, so its attempts to have that definitive decision disregarded under article 159 of the Constitution were ineffective. The pleas against the first decision therefore no longer needed to be examined. Both claims were dismissed. On costs: for the annulment action CWS counts as the prevailing party (the withdrawal is a disguised annulment), for the compensation claim the city does. Each was therefore entitled to a procedural indemnity against the other, both at the basic amount; CWS sought the maximum on account of a ‘manifestly unreasonable situation’ (unclear specifications and two earlier restarted procedures), the city 3,080 euros, but the Council saw no reason to depart from the basic amount and set the two indemnities off against each other. Charleroi bears 400 euros in roll fees and 48 euros in contributions for the suspension and annulment; CWS bears 200 euros in roll fees and a 24-euro contribution for the compensation claim.

Why does this matter?

The judgment draws a clear line around compensation claims in procurement litigation. A bidder who has the award suspended before the contract is concluded has thereby preserved its chance — and cannot at the same time claim compensation for losing it. That sounds logical, but it has a hard practical consequence: a bidder who, after a successful suspension, receives a new unfavourable award must challenge it. The loss of a chance then lies no longer in the first decision, but at most in the second, which here became definitive. Nor does the Council leave room to sideline a definitive individual decision via the plea of illegality under article 159 of the Constitution. CWS pointed to the risk of a ‘carousel’ of successive suspension proceedings that only well-funded bidders can sustain; the Council did not take that up. Positive for bidders is the confirmation that the Moors case law also applies after a withdrawal: the interest in compensation does not vanish because the authority withdraws its own decision. And the costs ruling shows that ‘without object’ and ‘dismissed’ in the same judgment can produce a draw, with the procedural indemnities cancelling each other out.

The lesson

For bidders: a suspension before the contract is concluded is a victory, not a ground for damages. If the authority withdraws its decision and takes a new one that again excludes you, that decision is your new target. If you let it become definitive, you can no longer argue later that it is unlawful in order to save a damages claim, and compensation for loss of a chance through the first decision falls away. So decide promptly whether to challenge the new decision; the cost and uncertainty of a second procedure are real, but standing still also costs you your leverage for compensation. For authorities: withdrawing a suspended award, resuming the procedure and properly notifying the new decision with the available remedies considerably limits your exposure to damages claims. But you do lose the annulment action against the withdrawn decision as a disguised annulment, with the roll fees and contributions to bear.

Ask yourself

As a bidder: has the contract already been concluded when you obtain the suspension? If not, do you realise that you will usually get no compensation for loss of a chance through that decision? If the authority, after a withdrawal, takes a new award decision excluding you, have you decided within the time limit whether to challenge it — knowing that otherwise it becomes definitive and can no longer be circumvented via article 159 of the Constitution? When filing a compensation claim, have you checked whether the damage actually materialised, and not merely whether the contested decision was unlawful? As an authority: do you notify a withdrawal and a new award decision to all bidders, stating the available remedies, so that they can become definitive?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →