Toit & Moi finds 40 minutes per boiler service unrealistic on the strength of its own statistics and figures from other housing companies — but never puts them to Jordan
The Council of State suspends, under the extreme-urgency procedure, the award of the maintenance of individual heating boilers to Vaillant Group Belgium, because Toit & Moi declared Jordan’s price abnormally low on the basis of ‘statistics’ from the current contract and ‘data’ from other social housing companies, without giving Jordan the opportunity to respond to that external information, as Article 36(3) of the Royal Decree of 18 April 2017 requires.
What happened?
On 19 December 2025 the social housing company Toit & Moi, active in the Mons region, decided to award a public services contract by open procedure for the heating maintenance of its dwellings in Mons, Frameries, Colfontaine and Quévy. The contract had two lots: lot 1 for the maintenance and repair of individual heating and domestic hot water installations, lot 2 for collective installations. The notice was published on 7 January 2026 in the Belgian Public Procurement Bulletin and the Official Journal of the EU, with a corrigendum on 4 February 2026. At the opening on 12 February 2026, two bids had been received for lot 1: from Établissements Jordan SA and from Vaillant Group Belgium SA. The specifications required a flat-rate price for the full servicing of an individual boiler of 15 to 30 kW, including all services described in point 2.1 of the technical provisions. On 18 March 2026 Toit & Moi asked both bidders to explain the composition of their unit price for item 2.1 ‘Servicing of individual boilers’, and on 14 April 2026 to justify that price under Article 36 of the Royal Decree of 18 April 2017. Jordan explained that it had assumed an average service time of forty minutes. The bid evaluation report of 13 May 2026 found that unachievable: ‘statistics from the contract currently being performed for the contracting authority’ and ‘data provided by other housing companies’ allegedly showed that a full service takes at least 50 to 60 minutes. Moreover, Jordan’s forty minutes also included contacting the tenant, handling absences and drafting the intervention report and inspection certificate; deducting a reasonable ten minutes for those tasks left, according to the report, thirty minutes for the actual technical work. On 22 May 2026 Toit & Moi declared Jordan’s bid irregular for an abnormally low price and awarded lot 1 to Vaillant Group Belgium. The decision was communicated on 4 June 2026; Jordan sought suspension under the extreme-urgency procedure on 15 June 2026. Vaillant Group Belgium intervened and filed its own table of the steps of a boiler service, as well as averages of services performed between May 2024 and April 2026, to show that forty minutes was unrealistic. The Council noted that neither Jordan’s plea nor Toit & Moi’s reply had been summarised, although the Royal Decree of 19 November 2024 requires it. On the merits, the Council examined only the first complaint: Toit & Moi had relied on information that did not come from the bidder. Article 36(3), third paragraph, of the Royal Decree of 18 April 2017 allows this, but obliges the contracting authority to give the bidder the opportunity to respond — according to the report to the King, a consequence of Article 69(3) of Directive 2014/24/EU, intended to safeguard the rights of defence and equal treatment. Neither the administrative file nor the evaluation report showed that the statistics and data had been put to Jordan before the decision on the normality of its price. The plea was serious. Toit & Moi identified no negative consequences of a suspension and the Council saw none. The award decision was suspended with immediate enforcement; the bids, the replies in the price verification and the intervention reports of three other housing companies (Habitations Sociales du Roman Païs, Le Logis Dourois and BHP Logement) remained confidential, and costs were reserved.
Why does this matter?
The judgment is not about whether forty minutes per boiler is realistic — the Council expresses no view on that. It is about how the contracting authority reaches its conclusion. An authority that uses its own experience figures or benchmarks from fellow authorities to rebut a price justification introduces a new element into the debate. Article 36(3) of the Royal Decree of 18 April 2017 turns that into an adversarial moment: the bidder must see the information and be able to answer it before the decision is taken. That is no formality. A bidder can ask precisely the questions that matter about statistics: which boilers, was travel time included, what counts as a ‘full service’? Without that opportunity, a bid is rejected on the basis of data the bidder has never seen. The judgment is also a reminder that even well-reasoned analysis — the authority held Jordan to its own administrative time — does not prevent suspension when the decision rests partly on undisclosed external data. For social housing companies, which often exchange figures, this is a practical point of attention.
The lesson
For contracting authorities: if your finding of an abnormal price relies on information that did not come from the bidder — your own statistics from a current contract, figures from other authorities, market studies — put it to the bidder before the decision and give a deadline to respond. Record that step in the file. A second justification request that explicitly mentions the benchmark costs little and avoids a suspension. For bidders: read the evaluation report carefully for references to ‘statistics’, ‘experience’ or ‘third-party data’ you have never seen. That is a concrete and verifiable plea, independent of whether your price holds up on the merits. And for both parties in summary proceedings: summarise your pleas and your reply, as the Royal Decree of 19 November 2024 requires.
Ask yourself
As a contracting authority: does your assessment of a price’s normality rely on figures the bidder did not supply itself? If so: did you send those figures to the bidder before the decision, and can you prove it with a document in the file? Did you give the bidder a reasonable deadline to respond to that external information? As a bidder: does the evaluation report refer to statistics, benchmarks or experience of other authorities that you never saw? Did your price justification make clear which tasks fall within the stated service time, so the authority cannot read your figure differently from what you meant? Does your petition or note of observations in summary proceedings contain the mandatory summary of your arguments?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →