Rejection French-speaking chamber

A gully with the wrong grate costs SACE a Liège framework agreement for road works: one substantial irregularity is enough

Ruling nr. 267404 · 14 July 2026 · VIe kamer (vakantiekamer, kort geding)

The Council of State refuses to suspend, under extreme urgency, the award of a Liège framework agreement for road works: SACE’s offer was rightly found substantially irregular because its price justification for item 590 referred to a gully with a removable grate where the specifications required a captive grate, and in an open procedure such an irregularity leaves the contracting authority no choice but to declare the offer null — so that the other complaints about prices, evaluation method and lots could no longer tip the balance.

What happened?

On 15 December 2025 the municipal council of Liège approved the launch of an open procedure for a multi-supplier framework agreement for road works on carriageways, pavements and public parks, and for similar works of public interest. The framework agreement ran for twelve months, renewable three times; it was a joint contract with the intermunicipal company CILE. The contract notice appeared on 6 January 2026 and, on 7 January 2026, in the Official Journal of the European Union. Eight bidders submitted an offer. On 11 March 2026 the city questioned several bidders, including SACE, on unit prices that appeared abnormally low or high. The award report of 1 June 2026 selected all bidders but declared five offers substantially irregular, including SACE’s. It gave two separate reasons. First, items 440 to 443 (toothed concrete kerbs for a tree-pit frame): SACE had priced a complete frame of four kerbs, whereas the specifications (p. 114) measured per piece; the unit prices were more than 60% above the estimate and the average of the other bidders and were considered abnormally high. Second, item 590 (supply of a gully for level adjustment): SACE justified its price with a quotation from Fondatel for a gully of type 103040LP (A8C), fitted with a removable grate, whereas the specifications required a captive grate for reasons of public safety. On 5 June 2026 the municipal executive designated the three remaining bidders as contractors; SACE was informed of the reasons by registered letter of 9 June 2026. On 24 June 2026 SACE sought the suspension under extreme urgency of that decision and, ‘insofar as necessary’, of the decision adopting the procurement documents. That second limb failed at once: the procurement documents had been approved on 15 December 2025, and SACE had known of their existence at the latest when it submitted its offer, so the fifteen-day time limit of article 23 of the Act of 17 June 2013 had long expired. On the merits, SACE argued that the contested items each represented less than 1% of its offer (0.24% to 0.62%), that the previous, similar contract it had itself performed provided for removable grates, that the price difference per gully was at most around ten euros, and that the kerb error was a correctable clerical mistake. The president of the vacation chamber, Pierre-Olivier de Broux, first examined the complaint about item 590. In an open procedure the contracting authority must declare a substantially irregular offer null; it has no discretion in doing so (art. 76(3) Royal Decree of 18 April 2017). The fact that the technical non-conformity only came to light during the price examination does not prevent it from being a substantial irregularity; the city therefore did not have to show that the price was abnormal or that the item was not negligible. SACE did not seriously contest the non-conformity itself, and its assertion — after the event, in the application and at the hearing — that it could supply compliant gullies at a comparable price during performance was not enough. Because this single ground already supported the exclusion, the Council did not examine the complaints about the kerbs. The second plea, on the evaluation method, and the third, on the absence of division into lots, contained no summary as required by article 2 of the rules of procedure since 1 September 2023, and the Council declined to fill that gap itself. Moreover, SACE had no interest in them: its offer had been lawfully excluded before the evaluation stage, the prospect of a restarted procedure is not a sufficient interest, and SACE did not show that a division into lots would have produced a lot without item 590. The application was dismissed, immediate enforcement of the judgment was ordered, the confidentiality of the offers and price justifications was maintained, and the costs, including the procedural indemnity, were reserved. First auditor Muriel Vanderhelst had advised to the same effect.

Why does this matter?

The judgment shows the order in which the Council of State reviews an exclusion when the contracting authority relies on several grounds. If one ground of substantial irregularity is sufficient, the other complaints become irrelevant — however convincing the story about negligible items or a clerical mistake may sound. It is also significant that the Council does not treat the price examination and the regularity check as watertight compartments: what a bidder writes in its price justification can reveal a technical non-conformity, which then simply falls under article 76. The justification is therefore not a free-standing arithmetic exercise but a document that helps define the offer. The judgment also repeats two procedural lessons that are increasingly decisive. A plea without a summary will not be reconstructed by the Council in summary proceedings. And a bidder lawfully excluded before the evaluation stage has no interest in criticising the evaluation method or the decision not to divide into lots, unless it shows concretely that this choice affected its exclusion. Finally, the judgment underlines that the approval of the procurement documents cannot be challenged ‘insofar as necessary’ in an action against the award: the fifteen-day time limit runs from knowledge, and that knowledge coincides at the latest with the submission of the offer.

The lesson

For bidders: proofread your price justification as if it were a technical offer. A supplier’s quotation you attach as evidence of your price must itself comply with the specifications — here a gully reference number with a removable grate betrayed the non-conformity. Promising afterwards that you will supply compliant material during performance does not save an open procedure. Summarise every plea in your application, and show for each plea concretely how the alleged error harmed you. If you want to challenge the procurement documents, do so within fifteen days of becoming aware of them, not only after the award. For contracting authorities: when the price examination reveals a technical deviation, you may treat it as a substantial irregularity, provided the award report explains why it makes performance uncertain (here: public safety if a grate goes missing). State each ground of exclusion separately and self-sufficiently; the decision then stands even if another ground wavers.

Ask yourself

Have you checked whether every document you attach to your price justification (supplier quotations, type numbers, data sheets) itself complies with the specifications? Do you understand that in an open procedure a single substantial irregularity is enough to have your offer declared null, regardless of how little the item weighs in your total price? Does every plea in your application contain a summary, and do you explain for each plea what concrete harm the alleged error caused you? Did you challenge the procurement documents in time, within fifteen days of becoming aware of them, if you considered them unlawful? As a contracting authority: does your award report state each ground of exclusion separately, with a concrete reason why the irregularity is substantial?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →