Rejection Dutch-speaking chamber

One hourly rate outside the framework agreement’s price band, and the bid for the Blankenberge–Zeebrugge cycle highway is out: the Roads Agency did not have to show any effects

Ruling nr. 267405 · 14 July 2026 · XIIe vakantiekamer

The Council of State dismisses the urgent suspension request of E. NV, whose bid for the design of the N34 and the F34 cycle highway between Blankenberge and Zeebrugge was declared substantially irregular because the unit rate of one item fell outside the -25% to +15% band relative to its framework-agreement prices: that band is a minimum requirement even though it is never called one, the acknowledged ‘issue’ with price revision did not make the specification ambiguous, and a bidder breaching a minimum requirement is excluded without the authority having to show a discriminatory advantage or distortion of competition.

What happened?

The Flemish Roads and Traffic Agency (Agentschap Wegen en Verkeer, Flemish Region) concluded, through an open procedure advertised nationally and at EU level, a framework agreement for ‘study assignments for various infrastructure projects on regional roads’ (specification AWV/INV/2021/2), in five lots. Lot 5, West Flanders, was awarded in 2022 to nine engineering firms, including E. NV. Specific assignments would be allocated through mini-competitions. The specification twice warned participants — once in bold and boxed in Article 43(6), and again under the price criterion — that the unit prices they quoted for the various job profiles in the framework contract ‘will also form the basis for pricing within the various mini-competitions’: adjustments were allowed, ‘but this unit price must fall within a band of (-25%; +15%)’. The specification also contained a price-revision clause (Article 38/7 of the General Implementing Rules), supplemented by an amendment in 2023 for orders with a call for tenders or conclusion after 1 January 2023. On 3 September 2024 the Agency wrote to all contractors that price revision had to be calculated using the submission date of the mini-competition bid as reference date, since prices are only given at that point. This, the letter said, was ‘separate from the -25% and +15% band’. The Agency added: ‘We are aware of the issue of the price bands not being revised; we are taking steps to work out a solution, albeit for future files.’ On 1 October 2025 the Agency invited the nine participants to mini-competition WWV/INV/N34/12/S1: the study and design of the redevelopment of the N34 and the F34 cycle highway between kilometre points 7.97 and 11.30 (Zeebrugge–Blankenberge), with a new road foundation, adapted profile, separate sewerage, footpaths and greenery. The award criteria were the bid price (60 points) and the approach/project organisation (40 points). Six participants submitted bids. The award report found that E. NV for item 16, and bidder W. for items 15, 16 and 17, had quoted unit rates outside the price band. The Agency treated the band as ‘a minimum requirement relating to the price element’ and, also ‘in view of the equality of bidders’, declared both bids substantially irregular under Article 76 of the Royal Decree on Award. The four remaining bids were assessed and the contract went to S. NV. E. NV was informed by registered letter and e-mail on 11 June 2026 and sought suspension under the extreme urgency procedure on 25 June 2026. E. NV did not dispute that item 16 fell outside the band, but argued that the relationship between the price band and price revision was ambiguous, as the Agency itself had acknowledged in its letter of 3 September 2024; that the Agency had thereby created a legitimate expectation that this overlap would not lead to exclusion on purely formal grounds; that the band had to be read together with price revision and therefore set aside; and that the Agency should have examined whether the deviation gave it a discriminatory advantage, distorted competition or prevented comparison. The Council rejected every point. Insofar as there was any lack of clarity, the letter of 3 September 2024 had removed it ‘unambiguously’ by stating that price revision and the price band are separate. Calling the non-revision of the bands an ‘issue’ to be solved ‘for future files’ did not mean the band was problematic or open to interpretation, and nothing showed this mini-competition was such a future file. No legitimate expectation that a bid outside the band would still be regular could therefore be derived from it. Nor was a conflict between band and price revision shown: the band concerns pricing in the bid, price revision belongs to the performance rules. The decisive point was the classification as a minimum requirement. It is primarily for the contracting authority to judge whether a provision is a minimum requirement; the Council reviews whether it gave that concept its correct scope. The mini-competition specification declared the framework agreement applicable ‘in full’, the band appeared twice, once in bold and boxed, and in mandatory terms (‘must fall within’). That the provision was not expressly labelled ‘substantial’ made no difference. Since Article 76(1), fourth paragraph, 3° is a separate ground of substantial irregularity, the Agency did not also have to show that the deviation had one of the effects listed in Article 76(1), third paragraph. That only one rate was involved changed nothing: in an open procedure the authority is obliged under Article 76(3) to declare a substantially irregular bid void, so there is no question of unreasonableness or disproportion. Criticism of the second ground (the effects of the deviation) was not examined: alongside the first ground, found lawful, it is a superfluous ground. The request was dismissed. E. NV bears the EUR 200 court fee, the EUR 26 contribution and EUR 770 in procedural costs.

Why does this matter?

Framework agreements with mini-competitions are common among large contracting authorities, and price bands on framework prices often feature in them. This judgment shows how strictly such a band operates: one rate outside it is enough to lose the whole bid, regardless of whether that single deviation distorts the comparison of bids. Legally, the core lies in two confirmations. First, a provision need not carry the label ‘minimum requirement’ or ‘substantial’ to be one: mandatory wording, repetition and visual emphasis (bold, boxed) weigh heavily. This is in line with earlier case law on technical limits in mini-competitions. Second, the two grounds in Article 76(1) of the Royal Decree on Award are autonomous: a bidder breaching a minimum requirement cannot defend itself by arguing that the deviation brought it no advantage. The effects-test argument, often invoked by bidders as a last resort, is therefore hopeless where minimum requirements are concerned. The judgment is also instructive on legitimate expectations. An authority openly acknowledging that its price bands have not kept pace with price revision and promising a solution ‘for future files’ creates no expectation of leniency in ongoing mini-competitions. For engineering firms bound to a framework agreement for years while wages rise, that is a hard but clear message: until the band is formally amended, it applies as written.

The lesson

For bidders under a framework agreement: at every mini-competition, check each unit rate against the band in the framework contract — not just the total. A spreadsheet that automatically verifies whether every profile rate lies between -25% and +15% of your original price is cheaper than a lost contract. If you think the band is no longer tenable after years of indexation, ask a question before submission or request a formal amendment; do not count on a letter in which the authority ‘acknowledges’ the problem to protect you afterwards. And do not expect the argument ‘my deviation gave me no advantage’ to neutralise a minimum requirement. For contracting authorities: if you want a condition to lead to exclusion, phrase it in mandatory terms, repeat it and have the mini-competition specification expressly declare the framework agreement applicable ‘in full’. An award report that names the deviation specifically (which item, which bidder) and states the legal basis in Article 76 will hold up. If you yourself acknowledge a problem with the bands, solve it through a formal amendment of the procurement documents rather than a vague promise for ‘future files’ — otherwise the risk of dispute remains.

Ask yourself

At your last mini-competition, did you compare each individual unit rate with the band in the framework contract, or only the total? Do you know that a provision can be a minimum requirement even if it is never called one, when it is worded in mandatory terms, repeated and visually emphasised? Do you realise that, when you breach a minimum requirement, you cannot argue that the deviation gave you no advantage or did not prevent comparison? If the band pinches after indexation, have you asked a question or requested a formal amendment before submission, rather than relying on a general letter from the authority? As a contracting authority: do your mini-competition specifications expressly declare the framework agreement applicable in full, and have you formally resolved acknowledged problems instead of postponing them?

About this database

The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →