Brussels cigarette butts: Fresh Tray may regularise two substantial irregularities, and a new plea that only surfaces during oral argument is inadmissible
The Council of State dismisses the application by the French company Tchaomegot Collecte against the award of the Brussels contract for the collection and recycling of cigarette butts to Fresh Tray: a contract already concluded and being performed does not prevent suspension of the award decision, but in a negotiated procedure below the EU threshold the city was entitled to let Fresh Tray regularise more than one substantial irregularity, the price verification had been carried out concretely, and the plea on partial versus full recycling, raised only at the hearing, breached procedural fairness.
What happened?
The City of Brussels put out to tender a renewable services contract on a schedule-of-prices basis for the collection and recycling of cigarette butts on its territory for 24 months (specifications AFA/014099/HMO, approved on 12 March 2026). It used a negotiated procedure without prior publication, below the EU threshold, with price as the sole award criterion; the contract could be renewed for twelve-month periods up to a maximum of 48 months. The butts come from the ashtrays on public litter bins, are collected by city staff and stored in 240-litre drums in a city building; the contractor picks them up roughly once a quarter, transports and recycles them. Four companies submitted offers. On 28 May 2026 the municipal executive found that the offer of Fresh Tray, from Heusden-Zolder, was affected by ‘several substantial irregularities’: the offer form was missing, and Fresh Tray had attached its ‘general rental conditions’, some of which conflicted with the specifications. Fresh Tray accepted the invitation to regularise, supplied the form and declared that it waived its general conditions insofar as they conflicted with the specifications. Tchaomegot Collecte’s offer was also substantially irregular: in item 1 it had priced the transport and recycling of 4 drums instead of the presumed 16, but after regularisation it maintained its unit price and arrived at 113,101.12 euros including VAT. Two other offers were declared null. Fresh Tray won the contract for 48,012.80 euros including VAT. Tchaomegot Collecte learned of the decision on 4 June 2026, received the reasoned award decision only on 11 June 2026, and on 26 June 2026 sought suspension under extreme urgency. Fresh Tray, which intervened, argued that no standstill applied and that the contract had already been awarded and was being performed. The president of the vacation chamber, Joëlle Sautois, rejected that objection: article 30(2) of the Act of 17 June 2013 prohibits suspension of the concluded contract itself, not of the detachable award decision; anyone who ‘has or has had’ an interest in the contract retains access to summary proceedings, even if the contract is already running or has been performed. Otherwise, where no waiting period applies, the contracting authority could itself decide whether its decision could be challenged in summary proceedings, which would breach the right to an effective remedy and article 160 of the Constitution. On the merits, Tchaomegot Collecte got nowhere. Its claim that Fresh Tray’s offer was late lacked a factual basis: the offer was submitted on time, only the form was missing. In a negotiated procedure below the EU threshold, article 76(5) of the Royal Decree of 18 April 2017 gives the contracting authority the choice between nullity and regularisation, and that discretion also applies where an offer shows several substantial irregularities — the opposite reading would precisely hollow out that discretion. On prices, Tchaomegot Collecte itself acknowledged that the mandatory price examination of article 36 did not apply here (§ 6). The price verification of article 35 was mandatory, and the comparative price table and analyses filed confidentially showed it had been carried out concretely; the statement in the decision was therefore not boilerplate. With only two regular offers, a Fresh Tray price close to the estimate and an estimate based on a 2024 contract, there was no manifest error. At the hearing Tchaomegot Collecte raised a new plea: Fresh Tray offered only partial recycling (of the cellulose acetate), and the specifications were so summary that the offers became incomparable. The Council accepts new pleas in extreme-urgency proceedings when they could only emerge from the administrative file, but procedural fairness requires them to be communicated in time. The city had filed its note and the file on Wednesday 8 July 2026 at 5 p.m.; Tchaomegot Collecte had three full working days before the hearing and gave no explanation for raising the plea only during its oral argument. The plea was declared inadmissible. Fresh Tray’s intervention was admitted, the application dismissed, the confidentiality of the documents maintained and the costs reserved. First auditor and head of section Christian Amelynck had advised to the same effect.
Why does this matter?
The judgment contains three useful clarifications. The first is procedural and a matter of principle: the fact that a contract has already been concluded or is even being performed does not make an application to suspend the award decision inadmissible. This matters especially for small contracts without a mandatory waiting period, where the authority can already sign the contract before the unsuccessful bidder goes to the Council. The Council thus refuses to hand the authority the key to summary proceedings. The second concerns regularisation: in a negotiated procedure below the EU threshold, the authority may allow every substantial irregularity to be regularised, even if there are several. Bidders who, in such a procedure, count on a competitor’s offer being automatically null are mistaken; the only test is whether the authority made its discretionary choice on accurate and relevant grounds, respecting equality and transparency. The third concerns prices: below the EU threshold in a negotiated procedure without publication, the price examination of article 36 does not apply, but the price verification of article 35 does, and it must be apparent concretely from the file. Finally, the judgment confirms a line the Council also drew in judgment no. 265.405: a new plea is possible in extreme-urgency proceedings, but a party that raises it only during oral argument, while it had days to announce it, loses it on grounds of procedural fairness.
The lesson
For bidders: in a negotiated procedure below the EU threshold, a substantial irregularity in a competitor’s offer does not guarantee its exclusion — the authority may allow regularisation, even for several defects at once. Aim your criticism at the reasoning behind that choice and at equal treatment, not at the mere existence of the irregularities. If you find a new plea in the administrative file, notify the other parties and the auditor in writing as soon as you discover it, not only at the hearing. Go to the Council even if the contract has already been signed: that does not make your application inadmissible. For contracting authorities: if you allow regularisation, state your reasons expressly in the award decision, irregularity by irregularity. Also put the price-verification documents (comparative tables, analyses) in the file, so that the statement ‘prices were verified’ is not dismissed as boilerplate. And state clearly in the specifications what recycling or processing outcome you expect, if you want to avoid offers with fundamentally different technical solutions being compared on price alone.
Ask yourself
Do you know that in a negotiated procedure below the EU threshold the authority may allow several substantial irregularities in a single offer to be regularised? If you discovered a new plea in the administrative file, did you notify the other parties and the auditor in writing before the hearing? Do you realise that a contract already concluded or being performed does not make your application to suspend the award decision inadmissible? Do you know whether the price examination of article 36 of the Royal Decree applies in your procedure, or only the price verification of article 35? As a contracting authority: can you show with documents in the file that you verified the prices concretely, and did you specify in the tender documents what technical outcome (e.g. full or partial recycling) you expect?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →