A Mauritanian bidder litigates against Enabel without a lawyer and asks for a hearing via WhatsApp: rejected twice over, before the technical rejection is even discussed
The Mauritanian company CPVR, acting without a lawyer, sought the suspension under extreme urgency of Enabel’s decision not to retain its tender for contract MRT24001-10154 on technical grounds, but the Council of State declared the application inadmissible because, despite an invitation to regularise, it did not produce its articles of association or proof of a decision to bring proceedings, and also dismissed it because it did not appear at the hearing — a hearing by WhatsApp video did not satisfy article 27/1 of the Council of State Act.
What happened?
Enabel, a public-law limited company with a social purpose, informed the Mauritanian company CPVR on 11 June 2026 that its tender for the public contract with reference MRT24001-10154 had not been retained, for reasons presented as technical. CPVR, based in Nouakchott, filed a single application on 20 June 2026 for suspension under extreme urgency and annulment of that decision. The application was signed by its director-general, without a lawyer, and contained no articles of association, no deed appointing its officers and no proof of a decision to bring proceedings. By an order of 24 June 2026 the case was listed for the hearing of 10 July 2026; in the email by which the registry sent that order — CPVR acknowledged receipt on 27 June 2026 — it was invited to regularise its application. It did not. In a ‘note in reply’ to Enabel’s observations, sent by email on 9 July 2026, CPVR announced documents but did not attach them. On the day of the hearing it sent, in two unreferenced emails, an extract from the commercial register and a certificate of change of tax identification. The same day it stated that it had unsuccessfully contacted several Belgian law firms and asked the Council to find a solution ‘by video (WhatsApp)’. At the hearing only Enabel’s lawyer appeared, asking that the note in reply be excluded. State Councillor Virginie Rolin first held that such a note is not provided for in the royal decree of 19 November 2024: it may be understood as a courtesy and is taken into account for information only, not as a procedural document, and new arguments that could have been made in the application are disregarded. On admissibility, she recalled that a legal person can only act validly before the Council if its competent body has so decided; a lawyer is presumed to have been mandated, but a party acting without one must produce its articles of association, the appointment of its officers and the decision to bring proceedings. The commercial-register extract and the tax certificate did not enable the Council to verify that such a decision had been taken or that the signatory was authorised to represent the company. The application was therefore inadmissible. Moreover, the proposed WhatsApp hearing was not a videoconference satisfying the cumulative conditions of article 27/1 of the coordinated laws, as CPVR was told by email before the hearing; since it was neither present nor represented, the application also had to be dismissed under article 11 of the royal decree of 19 November 2024. The Council kept confidential the tenders of CPVR and its competitors lodged by Enabel (documents 3 to 7). Because CPVR had also not elected domicile in Belgium and had not produced its articles of association, the annulment action could not be entered on the roll, and it was uncertain whether it ever would be. Costs were therefore settled at once: CPVR pays the roll fee of EUR 200, the contribution of EUR 26 and a procedural indemnity of EUR 770 to Enabel. Immediate enforcement of the judgment was ordered.
Why does this matter?
The judgment is a catalogue of procedural pitfalls for a bidder that goes to the Council of State without a Belgian lawyer — a scenario that can arise when foreign companies bid for a Belgian contracting authority. Four rules come together. One: a party represented by a lawyer benefits from the presumption that the lawyer is mandated; a legal person that is not must itself prove that its competent body decided to litigate and that the signatory may represent the company. A commercial-register extract does not prove that. Two: an invitation from the registry to regularise is a last chance, not a formality — a party that ignores it, or turns up on the day of the hearing with incomplete documents, loses. Three: the new interim-relief rules require attendance at the hearing, and a video hearing is an exception the chamber president may allow by reasoned order under strict conditions, not a WhatsApp call proposed by the applicant at the last minute. Four: a ‘note in reply’ does not exist in interim-relief proceedings; at most it is read for information. On top of that comes a costs rule with practical consequences: because the annulment action could not be entered on the roll, the Council did not wait for the merits and charged the costs — EUR 996 in total — to the applicant immediately. The judgment says nothing about the technical rejection itself: the case foundered entirely on procedure.
The lesson
If you are a foreign bidder wishing to challenge a decision of a Belgian contracting authority, instruct a lawyer entitled to appear before the Council of State — not only because they bring the presumption of mandate, but also because they handle the election of domicile in Belgium, the bundle of documents and attendance at the hearing. Look for that lawyer as soon as you receive the decision: time limits under extreme urgency are short and the hearing follows quickly. If you nevertheless proceed without a lawyer, attach your articles of association, the deed appointing your officers and the competent body’s decision to bring proceedings to the application, and respond immediately to any invitation to regularise. Do not count on a remote hearing: it is exceptional and must meet statutory conditions. If you are a contracting authority, raise admissibility defects and procedural documents the rules do not recognise at the hearing, and claim your procedural indemnity — even if the annulment action has not yet been entered on the roll, the Council may settle costs immediately.
Ask yourself
Is your company represented before the Council of State by a lawyer, and if not, have you attached the articles of association, the appointment of your officers and the decision to litigate to the application? Have you elected domicile in Belgium? Have you responded fully and on time to an invitation from the registry to regularise? Who will represent you at the hearing, and do you realise that a video hearing is only allowed exceptionally and by reasoned order? And as a contracting authority: have you checked the admissibility of the application before answering on the substance, and claimed your procedural indemnity?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →