‘Multiplex 8 mm’ is not beech: Mouscron could reject the cheapest bid for school chairs, even though, according to the manufacturer, the wood was in fact beech
The Council of State dismisses Alvan Diffusion’s challenge to the award of three lots of school furniture by the city of Mouscron to Frenkel: a bidder whose technical sheet only states ‘multiplex 8 mm’ where the specifications require a beech seat and backrest, or who offers a drawer unit with two drawers instead of three, submits a substantially irregular bid — even if the specifications never labelled that requirement as ‘minimum’, and even if the chair later turns out to be made of beech plywood.
What happened?
The city of Mouscron launched an open procedure for the ‘supply of furniture for the Sports School and the municipal schools of Mouscron’ (contract no. 2026-1078), estimated at 249,570 euros excluding VAT and thus above the EU threshold. The contract had sixteen lots, with price as the sole award criterion. The specifications required bidders to attach a technical description allowing the conformity of the products to be checked. For the chairs in lots 1 and 11 they required a beech seat and backrest; for item 1 of lot 2, a teacher’s desk with a fixed drawer unit with three drawers and a key. Alvan Diffusion was the cheapest bidder for all three lots: 76,746.35 euros, 25,080.91 euros and 7,757.39 euros including VAT, against 107,377.43 euros, 37,861.44 euros and 12,310.42 euros for competitor Frenkel. For lots 1 and 11, Alvan offered the ‘SDE’ chair, whose attached sheet described a ‘chair with overhanging seat and backrest in multiplex 8 mm’. Only after the award did Alvan provide the manufacturer’s full sheet, which states that the seat and backrest are made of 8 mm beech plywood — as does the manufacturer’s website. In its bid evaluation report of 27 August 2026, the city found that ‘multiplex’ did not meet the beech requirement and explained why that requirement mattered: beech is hard yet elastic, flexes slightly under body weight and follows the curve of the back, which is important for school chairs on which children sit for hours on end. For lot 2, it noted that the drawer unit had only two drawers, offering insufficient storage. On 7 September 2026 the municipal board declared Alvan’s bid for lots 1, 2 and 11 substantially irregular and awarded those lots to Frenkel as the only regular bid. Alvan did win lots 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 12 and 13. A request for re-examination of 16 September 2026 was rejected on 18 September: the full sheet had not been submitted with the bid. Alvan applied to the Council of State under extreme urgency on 24 September 2026. The application was inadmissible insofar as it targeted the evaluation report: that report is not in itself a decision of the contracting authority within the meaning of article 14 of the law of 17 June 2013, even where the board adopts its content. On the merits, Alvan raised two pleas. The first — the city had confused a manufacturing technique (multiplex) with a wood species (beech), could have checked the manufacturer’s website or should have asked, and had asked Frenkel for clarifications — failed. Alvan itself admitted that its bid did not state the wood species, and the report described Frenkel’s chairs as ‘beech plywood’, showing that the city did grasp the distinction. Under article 66(3) of the law of 17 June 2016, a request for clarification is a power of the contracting authority, not a right of the bidder; the fact that Frenkel was questioned on other lots and other points does not show any concrete unequal treatment. The second plea — the requirements had not been designated as minimum or substantial in the specifications — failed too: a requirement can be a minimum requirement without that express label, and the city had explained in its report why it was. The president of the VIth chamber dismissed the application, ordered the immediate enforcement of the judgment and reserved the costs.
Why does this matter?
The judgment sets the bar for bid regularity at a point that is painfully concrete for bidders: what counts is what the bid says, not what would actually be delivered. According to the manufacturer’s full sheet, Alvan’s chair was indeed beech plywood, and Alvan was almost 48,000 euros cheaper than Frenkel across the three lots — yet the award stands, because the sheet did not state the wood species. The Council also clarifies how this relates to its own judgment no. 266.042 of 17 March 2026, in which the Forest CPAS could not simply reject nappies with 10 ml less absorption as substantially irregular. Not every technical specification is a minimum requirement, but a requirement about the wood species in a contract for wooden furniture, or about the number of drawers in a drawer unit, goes to the core of what the authority is buying — something that ‘cannot escape a company specialised in supplying furniture’. A slight difference in dimensions, by contrast, may be non-substantial, as the city itself accepted for Alvan’s oval table in lot 2. Decisive, too, is that the city explained in its evaluation report why it considered those requirements essential; it then need not additionally show that the irregularity produces one of the effects listed in article 76(1), third paragraph. Finally, the judgment confirms two procedural points: the evaluation report is not a separately challengeable act, and the power to request clarification remains discretionary, breaching equal treatment only where concretely unequal treatment in comparable situations is shown.
The lesson
Bidders: make your technical sheet cover every requirement of the specifications literally. If beech is required, write ‘beech plywood’, not ‘multiplex’; if three drawers are required, offer three. A full manufacturer’s sheet supplied only after the award will not save you, and the authority need not search the manufacturer’s website or call you. Nor should you count on the absence of the word ‘minimum’ making a requirement optional: features that go to the core of the product being bought are treated as minimum requirements. Challenge the award decision, not (only) the evaluation report. Contracting authorities: this judgment shows how to do it right. Mouscron explained concretely in its report why beech and three drawers were essential (comfort during hours of sitting, storage capacity) and distinguished this from a non-substantial dimensional deviation. If you treat requirements not expressly labelled as minimum as such anyway, make that reasoning visible. And if you ask bidders for clarification, do so consistently where similar ambiguities arise.
Ask yourself
Does your technical sheet literally state, for each product, the materials, wood species, quantities and dimensions required by the specifications — or just a general product description? Are you counting on the authority to look up missing information itself or ask you for clarification? Do you know that this is a power, not a duty? Do you assume that a requirement not labelled ‘minimum’ or ‘substantial’ cannot be a ground for rejection? As an authority: did you explain in the evaluation report why a requirement not expressly designated as minimum is nonetheless essential to what you are buying? As an authority: do you put clarification questions to all bidders in a comparable situation? Is your action directed against the award decision itself, and not only against the bid evaluation report?
About this database
The Council of State (Raad van State / Conseil d'État) is Belgium's supreme administrative court. In disputes over public procurement — from contract awards to tenderer exclusions — the Council of State is the final arbiter. The rulings in this database are summarised by TenderWolf in plain language, with practical lessons for tenderers and contracting authorities. View all rulings →